What Cheese Makes The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Don't Miss

Bacon Jam And Ricotta Grilled Cheese

Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich

There’s nothing quite like bacon jam. Let’s be realthis is the edible form of crack. It’s sweet and salty goodness comes from slowly rendering bacon and then cooking it down with brown sugar, caramelized onions, and red wine vinegar until a thick and chunky jam develops. Add some fresh ricotta, nutty parmesan, and crispy Brussels sprouts and you’ve got one serious bacon jam and ricotta sandwich on your hands.

The Secret Ingredient For The Best Grilled Cheese

My cheesemonger friend got me onto using mayonnaise instead of butter.

Its always spreadable, it gives you a fabulous golden-brown crust thats not as apt to burn as butter, and it offers just a little zip.

My favorite brands are Hellmanns/Best Foods and Dukes. I havent tried Miracle Whip , but I figure its too sweet to work well here. You can also make your own mayoits actually just as easy as making a grilled cheese!

Give mayonnaise a shot! Use the same amount as you would butter.

If you are 100 percent Team Butter, I understand. You can either butter the bread directly or melt a pat of butter in the pan. I prefer to butter the bread directly, but lets say your butter is straight from the fridge and rock-hard. In that case, melt it in the pan.

One of my colleagues here at Simply Recipes swears by this approach and uses it in his Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches.

Choose A Cooking Method

When it comes to cooking your grilled cheese, you have three options.

  • Stovetop: A standard skillet is the most straightforward and convenient method. Preheat a skillet over medium-low heat, then cook the assembled sandwich uncovered, flipping halfway through, until both sides are golden, about 3 to 4 minutes per side.
  • Oven: Making grilled cheese for a crowd? Save yourself time and effort and simply cook sandwiches on a rimmed baking sheet in a 450-degree F oven. Cook, flipping halfway through, until the cheese is melty and the bread golden, about 10 minutes total.
  • Panini Press: For a maximum crispy sear with minimal effort, try cooking grilled cheese in a panini press. Preheat a panini press to medium heat, place sandwich in press, close the top and cook until lightly browned and the cheese is melted, about 5 to 6 minutes.

Read Also: Does Laughing Cow Need Refrigeration

Favorite Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Sometimes nothing short of a grilled cheese sandwich will suffice. You understand what Im talking about? Similarly, there are occasions when a grilled cheese sandwich is the only vegetarian choice available to me. In my life, Ive been let down by several grilled cheese sandwiches, so I set out to develop the best grilled cheese recipe I could find. A favoritegrilled cheese sandwich that I could whip up whenever the mood struck me was my goal for this recipe. I was looking for gourmet flavor without the use of complex components or preparation procedures.

  • I should also admit that I aspire to become well-known for my grilled cheese sandwiches someday in the future.
  • I want my future offspring to be able to brag about their mothers grilled cheese sandwich making abilities.
  • So, here we are, with my go-to grilled cheese recipe, which you can find below.
  • Continue reading for my tips and techniques, since I have a few to share with you!

How Much Cheese To Use


This is a very personal issue. Its possible to overdo it, but no one wants a skimpy grilled cheese, either. Theres plenty of space in the middle ground.

Two ounces of cheese per sandwich is a good rule of thumb, but a better rule of thumb is to eyeball it. Three ounces gives you a more decadent grilled cheese. Its your call!

Either way, grate as much cheese as you need to pile loosely on both slices of bread. A good, fluffy handful should do it.

Read Also: How Long Does Babybel Last In The Fridge

Green Bean Casserole Grilled Cheese

This green bean casserole takes all the goodness from the classic dish and transforms it into a holdable green bean casserole grilled cheese sandwich. Camembert not only adds a richness to the sandwich, but it also mocks the gravy aspect of the dish. And by adding the french onion dip seasoning to the top, you get even more of that awesome retro-ness.

  • 17 of 28 Grilled Cheese Social

    This roasted artichoke grilled cheese is unique and impressive.

    We always think about marinated artichoke hearts but have you ever tried your hand at roasting them? Not only does this bring out their natural sweetness, but when oven-roasted, the artichokes texture completely transforms into a more crunchy and caramelized version of its soggy self.

    In this sandwich, we combine the crispy and golden roasted artichoke hearts with creamy and rich Mecox cheddar between two slices of sourdough and a hefty drizzle of hot pepper-infused olive oil. This sandwich may sound simple, but the flavors are totally complex and exciting.

  • Fn: Cover: May2010 134881tif

    Make your own custom creation by experimenting with different types of bread, cheese and fillings. We love the combination of textures and flavors here, with creamy, funky Tallegio, thinly sliced deli ham, and crisp, sweet-tart green apple slices, all sandwiched between griddled slices of white bread slicked with olive oil.

    Ina Garten makes the case for grilled cheese as scene-stealing garnish with her grilled cheese croutons set adrift in a bowl of homemade tomato soup. Grated Gruyere, one of our favorite melting cheeses, is sandwiched between sturdy slices of country white bread slathered with unsalted butter and cooked on a panini grill until nicely browned. As Ina would say, How easy is that?

    Related Links:

    Read Also: Charcuterie Board Lunchable

    Brie And Other Bloomy Rind Cheeses

    Brie, Camembert, and other bloomy rind cheeses are just as luscious when melted as they are at room temperature. Choose varieties that are firm enough to slicethis often means seeking out younger specimensand save the ripe wheels to enjoy as they are on a cheese board.

    Bloomy rinds are super versatile between slices of bread. They pair beautifully with slices of seasonal fresh fruit as well as fruit preserves, honey, charcuterie, roasted mushrooms, or tomatoes.

    Why Are My Grilled Cheese Sandwiches Soggy

    How to Make The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich (Gourmet Grilled Cheese Recipe)

    Anything less than 1 will make a flimsy, soggy grilled cheese and anything too thick will not allow the cheese to melt properly. Thick-cut classic white bread that you find in the super market can work, but avoid Wonder Bread or similarly squishy bread. Go for a block of natural cheese that tastes good and melts well.

    You May Like: Can I Eat Grilled Cheese After Tooth Extraction

    Everything You Need To Know About Making The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Mayo Or Butter Lid On Or Off There’s More To A Good Grilled Cheese Recipe Than You Might Think

    A grilled cheese sandwich is the first thing a lot of people learn to cook. It was the first thing I learned to cook. Id shave off a few slices from the ubiquitous big orange block of Velveeta in our fridge, slather Roman Meal bread with Promise margarine, and make the best meal nine-year-old me could ever want.

    Maybe you didnt grow up grilling processed cheese on squishy sandwich bread. Or maybe you know plenty well how to make grilled cheese, but you want to up your game. Great newsthis grilled cheese party is open to all experience levels!

    New York Grilled Cheese

    The New York Grilled Cheese in Florida serves up your favorite sandwich as a waffle! With the tagline, not your mothers grilled cheese, these sandwiches are perfectly crispy on the outside with warm, gooey cheese inside. All the grilled cheese names are attributes to New York, with names like the Wall Street Grinder and Brooklyn Porkster.

    All the sandwiches are heavenly, but we love the Time Square Pizza Melt. This sandwich has roasted pepperoni, housemade marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, and a garlic butter spread on a waffled country loaf. The Midtown Truffle Shuffle is a close second, which comes with garlic and herb-roasted mushrooms, melted mozzarella, caramelized onions, Swiss cheese, and truffle aioli.

    Recommended Reading: Hazen Meats

    Burnett Dairy Wood River Creamery Cheddar Gruyere

    While blending cheeses yourself can deliver the perfect mix of melt-ability and flavor, this award-winning cheese scores high on Brownes list because it comes pre-mixed: A cheddar cheese blended with cultures traditionally reserved for sweeter Swiss-style cheeses, this cheddar gruyere combo taste better than the sum of its parts, Browne says.

    Related: Best Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup Recipes

    Pastrami Reuben With Cheddar Grilled Chese

    Fancy Schmancy Grilled Cheese

    There’s a ton of variations for the Reuben sandwich, and some people have said that this recipe resembles a sandwich known as the Rachelthat is if you swap the pastrami for turkey and the cheddar out for Swiss cheesebut this buttery rich sandwich deserves its own category.

    In this Rueben spin-off recipe, sharp cheddar cheese is melted over warm peppery pastrami, creamy coleslaw, and zesty Thousand Island dressing. Everything is sandwiched between two slices of rye bread and is grilled until crispy and buttery.

  • 28 of 28
  • Recommended Reading: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

    Cheese On The Outside You Bet

    Try sprinkling some shredded cheese directly onto your buttered skillet and then placing the bread right on top of it. Once the sizzling stops your cheese is melted on to your bread.

    Youll get an extra crispy, cheesy crust that is absolutely the best thing youll ever eat! Dont worry, as long as you cook the sandwiches on a lower heat, the cheese wont burn.

    Recommended Reading: How Much Does Shredded Cheese Cost

    Taleggio And Other Washed Rind Cheeses

    One of the keys to great grilled cheese is finding a wedge with the right combination of texture and flavorand many washed rind wheels fit the bill perfectly. These cheeses have the right balance of moisture and fat to melt like a dream, and their pungent aromas and rich, buttery flavor make an ideal base for tasty add-ins

    Instead of grating, choose a variety thats firm enough to be cut into thin slices, then layer those in with pickled asparagus spears, savory slices of prosciutto, apricot jam, or slices of juicy ripe tomato.

    Don’t Miss: Laughing Cow Cheese Refrigerate

    How I Tested The Grilled Cheese Recipes

    Wherever possible, I used the same brands of cheese and bread for all four recipes. I cooked all the sandwiches back-to-back, and with the exception of the bread, I kept the ingredients refrigerated until I was ready to make the sandwich . I tasted each sandwich immediately after making it so that I could judge them while they were hot and fresh.

    The 10 Best Cheeses To Take Your Grilled Cheese To The Next Level

    The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe

    Theres nothing quite like a hot, crispy, ooey-gooey grilled cheesebut this comforting classic is so much more than American singles and white bread.

    The next time youre craving grilled cheese, try melting some of these new-to-you varieties. These are the 10 best cheeses to use in a grilled cheese sandwichplus recommendations for varieties to try in our online cheese shop.

    You May Like: Where Can I Buy Brick Cheese

    Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipes

    The Spruce / Cara Cormack

    While grilled cheese usually is only thought to be something we eat during lunch, the truth is that this sandwich can be eaten at any time of the dayeven breakfast. This list of recipes will show you how to take the classic grilled cheese recipe up a notch or make something else entirely.

    What Can I Add To Grilled Cheese

    Grilled cheese can have anything you want. Sometimes grilled cheese also has more ingredients besides bread and cheese. They include ingredients such as slices of ham, caramelized onions, apples, pears, or tomatoes . Some chutneys such as mango chutney, peach chutney, or apple chutney can also be added to the melted cheese.

    To make grilled cheese sandwich with a twist, add some types of jam, peanut butter, or Nutella. You need to sprinkle them on the cheese when it melts. They would take your grilled cheese sandwich to the next level.

    Don’t Miss: Babybel Refrigeration

    Best Bread For Grilled Cheese:

    This is what making grilled cheese is all about!

    • Use whatever bread you love, but make sure it is sturdy enough to hold the cheese in.
    • White bread and sourdough are the most popular, but even a thickly sliced boule will make a perfect grilled cheese!
    • Dark rye and pumpernickel pair well with lighter cheeses like Gouda or Havarti

    The Best Pan For Grilled Cheese

    11 Best Cheeses For Grilled Cheese Sandwiches, Because ...

    The pan is just as important, if not more so, than the bread and cheese. A flimsy skillet will grill your sandwich unevenly. A skillet thats too small makes it hard to maneuver the sandwich.

    For one sandwich at a time, I like a 10-inch cast-iron skillet.

    Grilled cheese sandwiches dont really stick to the pan, so if you dont have a nonstick pan, its fine. I prefer a cast-iron pan.

    Read Also: Chuck E Cheese Plate

    What’s The Best Way To Make A Grilled Cheese Sandwich

    Despite its name, grilling is not necessarily the best way to make a grilled cheese sandwich, as it will melt the cheese on top but leave the bread uncooked underneath. The best way to make a grilled cheese sandwich is in a cast-iron skillet. An alternative is in a sandwich maker or sandwich grill, which does an adequate job.

    Our Best Panini And Grilled Sandwich Recipes

    Spread one french bread slice with pesto. Set aside. Butter the other slice of french bread. Place butter side down onto a heated skillet. Add cheese onto bread. Place other slice of bread with pesto on top . Press down the top of the sandwich with a heavy skillet until sandwich flattens like a panini.

    Brush top and bottom of each sandwich with olive oil. Place in a panini grill and press until bread is crisp and brown, and cheese has melted slightly, 9 to 10 minutes. If using a grill pan, preheat over medium-high heat. Place a heavy pan on top of sandwiches and press down. Cook, turning once, 2 to 3 minutes per side.

    To make caramelised onion and cheese panini, heat the oil in a broad non-stick pan, add the onions, sugar and salt, mix well and cook on a medium flame for 7 minutes, while stirring continuously. Keep aside. Slit a hot dog roll horizontally using a sharp knife and apply 1 tsp of butter on each halve.

    Tip 1. If You Dont Have a Panini Grill. Heat skillet on medium heat. Cook sandwich 3 min. on each side or until cheese is melted and sandwich is golden brown on both sides, gently pressing down top of sandwich with spatula to flatten slightly as it cooks. Tip 2. Serving Suggestion.

    1. Spread bread slices with dressing fill with remaining ingredients. 2. Cook in heated grill pan or small skillet sprayed with cooking spray on medium heat 5 min. on each side or until golden brown on both sides.

    You May Like: Can Babybel Cheese Go Bad

    Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe

    Theres Grilled Cheese and theres GREAT Grilled Cheese. Learn how to make the best Grilled Cheese Sandwich with a crisp, buttery exterior and gooey cheese center.

    Try this combination of cheeses and the process for buttering and cooking the toast and you will be known for your Grilled Cheese Sandwiches. All you need is a Creamy Tomato Soup to dunk your sandwich into.

    This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.

    We love hot sandwiches from our Crispy Chicken Sandwich to Philly Cheesesteak. This Grilled Cheese recipe is well-loved by the whole family. Who can resist that impressive cheese pull? Watch the video tutorial and see how easy it is. All you need is a skillet and a spatula.

    Gruyre Comt And Other Hard Alpine Cheeses

    How To Make The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich | The Best Way

    Take inspiration from fondue, another Swiss melted cheese tradition, with this cheese family. Younger and longer-aged Alpine cheeses are often blended together to create the perfect combination of gooey stretch and savory in the fondue pot.

    Between slices of bread, you can use just about any Alpine cheesekeeping in mind that very hard, crystalline varieties should be blended with something softer and milder to create the perfect texture. Add in peppery arugula, slices of tart apple, or a dollop of pepper jelly for contrast.

    You May Like: Does Harry And David Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

    Be Choosy With Cheese

    Choosing flavorful cheeses like Gruyère, sharp cheddar, Gouda, and havarti bring a richer, distinct flavor to your grilled cheese. You also may find yourself using less cheese, since their flavors are bolder than that of American cheese.

    Using less cheese means fewer calories for your sandwich, but it doesnt mean you have to lose that cheesy goodness and flavor.

    What Is The Best Bread For Grilled Cheese

    White bread or sourdough are my go-to breads for late-night grilled cheese cravings. You just have to make sure that your bread is thick and sturdy enough to hold all that cheese inside.

    A good white bread grills so nicely and is neutral so the cheese is the star of the show.

    Nice, crusty artisan breads are also ideal for a grilled cheese. Make sure they arent too lacy and open, or too dense and thick.

    Challah or Brioche are also yummy! Just make sure the slices arent too thick so the cheese can still melt.

    If youre getting a little more gourmet, rye and pumpernickel go great with some lighter cheeses such as havarti or gouda. Or go with Swiss and deli mustard for some Reuben vibes.

    Sometimes I like to make grilled cheese with a sunflower seed or whole wheat to make my sandwich feel a bit healthier. But generally, there isnt an ideal bread for grilled cheese, it just comes down to what you like best!

    Read Also: Unrefrigerated String Cheese

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This