How Do You Make Grilled Cheese With Mayo

Don't Miss

What Kind Of Bread Should I Use

How to Make a Grilled Cheese Sandwich in the Air Fryer

There are many different types of bread available at grocery stores, but the best type to use depends on what kind of flavor profile you want your sandwich to have. If youre looking for a soft, chewy texture to complement creamy cheeses like Brie or Camembert then sourdough bread may be the best choice for you. However, if you want something with a little more bite then try using rye or wheat bread instead! You can even try making your own bread at home if you want something truly unique!

Should You Use Mayo Or Butter For Grilled Cheese

But it makes perfect sense when you think about the ingredients used to make mayonnaisethat creamy texture comes from whipping egg yolks and oil. Using mayo instead of butter to make grilled cheese results in a rich, golden brown exterior, and some say the taste is even better than butter!Oct 1, 2020.

Why You Should Fry Your Grilled Cheese In Mayonnaise

Weve already featured Jamie Olivers toasted cheese and Noras Dads grilled cheese this week. Now its time for a gilled cheese tip from Blood, Bones and Butter author Gabrielle Hamilton, as revealed in the Holiday issue of Canal House Cooking. Her unusual grilled cheese method? Spreading the outsides of the bread with mayonnaise instead of butter before frying. This was something I had to try! Read on for my review.

First, let me say this: I know some people might be unsure about hot mayonnaise but using a store-bought brand is perfectly safe. While its somewhat unusual, I have used mayo in hot dishes before with no problems and excellent results.

Ms. Hamilton instructs us to spread the outsides of the sandwich with mayo and fry it up in a non-stick skillet over lowish heat. I gave it a try with a simple whole grain bread and a nice, sharp cheddar. The results? Sublime! The mayo browned nicely into a delicious crust and offered a rich, slightly tangy flavor.

This is going to be my go-to method for grilled cheese from now on.

Gabrielle Hamilton served her grilled cheese sandwiches to company at Christmastime, along with glasses of chilled, crisp champagne. Besides the usual cheddar with mustard, she also made a blue cheese and bacon on pumpernickel and cheddar with mango and jalapeno. Yum!

You May Like: How Much Is Chuck E Cheese Tickets

Choose A Cooking Method

When it comes to cooking your grilled cheese, you have three options.

  • Stovetop: A standard skillet is the most straightforward and convenient method. Preheat a skillet over medium-low heat, then cook the assembled sandwich uncovered, flipping halfway through, until both sides are golden, about 3 to 4 minutes per side.
  • Oven: Making grilled cheese for a crowd? Save yourself time and effort and simply cook sandwiches on a rimmed baking sheet in a 450-degree F oven. Cook, flipping halfway through, until the cheese is melty and the bread golden, about 10 minutes total.
  • Panini Press: For a maximum crispy sear with minimal effort, try cooking grilled cheese in a panini press. Preheat a panini press to medium heat, place sandwich in press, close the top and cook until lightly browned and the cheese is melted, about 5 to 6 minutes.

The Secret Ingredient For The Best

secret to the best grilled cheese ever: spread mayo instead of butter ...

We can all agree that everyone loves new ways to improve on old favourites. Do you know how to make a perfect hard-boiled egg? Or how to use a hairdryer for the best-ever Thanksgiving turkey? Now you do!

One of the latest and greatest kitchen hacks involves upgrading your grilled cheese with one simple secret ingredient: mayonnaise.

Recommended Reading: How Long To Cook Bubba Burgers

Read Also: What Is Good With Mac And Cheese

How To Make A Grilled Cheese On The Grill

Get a grill ready for direct grilling over medium heat.

Get out two slices of bread. Spread one side of each with softened butter or mayonnaise. . Flip the bread slices over. Put a couple of cheese slices onto one slice of bread. Invert the other bread onto it so that it is butter-side-up.

Transfer the sandwich to the preheated grill. Cook for 2-3 minutes, until grill marks appear. Shift the sandwich around, moving it 90 degrees. Cook for another minute or two, to get those lovely hash marks.

Flip the sandwich over and repeat on the second side, cooking for 2-3 minutes to get the initial grill marks and then turning the sandwich 90 degrees to create hashmarks.

Recommended Reading: How To Remove Grill Grease From Concrete

The Open Face Technique

For years, I assembled the sandwich and then grilled it. But recently I came across a new technique I like a lot better. Lets call it: Open-face grilling.

Open-face grilling allows the cheese to melt more thoroughly. The tradeoff is you can only make one sandwich at a time. But if its perfection you want, this is your method.

  • Put both slices of bread in the skillet butter-side-down
  • Arrange half the cheese over each slice. Once its halfway melted, invert one slice onto the other.
  • Press down lightly with a spatula .
  • Finish grilling as needed until the cheese is melted and both sides of the bread are golden brown.

Open-face grilling makes it easy to insert accouterments like tomato slices or chutney midway through grilling. The partially melted cheese bonds to the filling and keeps it from sliding around.

If you prefer a technique that allows you to grill two sandwiches at once, our very own Elise Bauer has a splendid tutorial on her assembly method.

You May Like: Should I Stop Eating Cheese To Lose Weight

Everything You Need To Know About Making The Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich Mayo Or Butter Lid On Or Off Theres More To A Good Grilled Cheese Recipe Than You Might Think

A grilled cheese sandwich is the first thing a lot of people learn to cook. It was the first thing I learned to cook. Id shave off a few slices from the ubiquitous big orange block of Velveeta in our fridge, slather Roman Meal bread with Promise margarine, and make the best meal nine-year-old me could ever want.

Maybe you didnt grow up grilling processed cheese on squishy sandwich bread. Or maybe you know plenty well how to make grilled cheese, but you want to up your game. Great newsthis grilled cheese party is open to all experience levels!

Recommended Reading: How To Get Grease Off Of Driveway

Can You Use Pam To Make Grilled Cheese

Mayonnaise Grilled Cheese Taste Test – Summertime Hamburger Hacker

Forget about all that fatty butter and margarine, making grilled cheese sandwiches with PAM is faster, healthier and delicious. Set your skillet to medium and spray one side of a slice of bread with PAM cooking spray. Place the sprayed side of your bread face down in the pan and place a slice of cheese on top of it.

Recommended Reading: What Is A Good Cheese For Mac And Cheese

The Secret Ingredient For The Best Grilled Cheese

My cheesemonger friend got me onto using mayonnaise instead of butter.

Its always spreadable, it gives you a fabulous golden-brown crust thats not as apt to burn as butter, and it offers just a little zip.

My favorite brands are Hellmanns/Best Foods and Dukes. I havent tried Miracle Whip , but I figure its too sweet to work well here. You can also make your own mayoits actually just as easy as making a grilled cheese!

Give mayonnaise a shot! Use the same amount as you would butter.

If you are 100 percent Team Butter, I understand. You can either butter the bread directly or melt a pat of butter in the pan. I prefer to butter the bread directly, but lets say your butter is straight from the fridge and rock-hard. In that case, melt it in the pan.

One of my colleagues here at Simply Recipes swears by this approach and uses it in his Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwiches.

What Can I Use Instead Of Butter To Make Grilled Cheese

5 Best Substitutes for Butter in Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

  • Eggs. Eggs make an excellent replacement for butter.
  • Olive Oil. Using olive oil in your grilled cheese will make the sandwich much healthier than using regular butter.
  • Mayo. This is probably the most well-known and often used replacement for butter in making grilled cheese sandwiches.
  • Bacon Grease.
  • Recommended Reading: Can I Have Blue Cheese Dressing On Keto

    Is Mayonnaise Good On Grilled Cheese

    Its texture is better, and the ingredients in it serve you better, rather than the grilled cheese sandwich sandwich being overly salty. The taste is not ideal, however. While we still prefer traditionally softened butter, be sure to use mayonnaise, if no butter is available on your counter. Im pretty sure youll be satisfied with the results.

    Read Also: Is Babybel Cheese Pasteurized

    Best Bread For Grilled Cheese

    How to Make the Best Grilled Cheese Using Mayo

    For making grilled cheese sandwiches, you can use any bread you like. The only thing you need to remember is that the bread sliced should be thick and sturdy enough for the cheese. You can also use artisan bread. If you are using artisan bread or homemade loaf, make sure to slice bread into evenly thick slices to get the perfect grilled cheese.

    Read Also: How To Make Fried Mac And Cheese

    How Much Cheese To Use For Grilled Cheese

    I used two slices of cheddar cheese. Next time, my son mentioned that he wanted to switch that out for Mexican cheese. So, I think that will be coming up.

    The trick to getting stuff to stay put during the cooking process, especially bread and light items is a toothpick here, I put a toothpick in each corner of the bread. It worked wonderfully, and the result was awesome. I also lifted the grilled cheese by placing it on the trivet that I was lucky to get in my air fryer accessory kit, which meat that the mayonnaise did not stick to the air fryer basket. So, each side had a nice coating.

    What Is An Air Fryer

    An air fryer is a small kitchen device that operates by hot air spinning around the food, causing it to crisp up.

    The hot air from the heating element and the fan blows around the food, cooking it up. Since the size of the air fryer is smaller than an oven, the air fryer cooks the food so much quicker.

    Read Also: Where Can I Buy Teleme Cheese

    Also Check: Does Kraft Sell Powdered Cheese

    Should You Slice Or Grate The Cheese

    We’re big fans of sliced cheese, which yields even coverage and optimal meltiness, as long as you start with slices of uniform thickness. But shredding has its advantages, too. It tends to melt faster than sliced cheese, which ensures that all the cheese melts before the bread finishes toasting. Be sure to sprinkle shredded cheese in an even layer and corral any stray pieces sticking out of the sides . You can also opt to add a bit of softened butter to bind the grated cheese and make a spread, all the better to contain the cheese between the bread.

    Armando Rafael

    How To Make Grilled Cheese With Olive Oil

    Grilled Cheese Sandwich & Tomato Soup (I can’t believe this trick worked) | Weeknighting

    In order to make grilled cheese with olive oil, simply coat your pan with enough olive oil to keep the sandwich from sticking, usually about 1-2 tablespoons, the same way you would with butter. You may or may not need to add more oil between flips. Be careful not to use too much oil when cooking your sandwich as this can render the sandwich too oily.

    Remember that cooking with olive oil can impart a very potent taste to your sandwich. Use light-tasting olive oil to prevent overpowering your sandwich.

    Read Also: Temp To Cook Pork Chops On Grill

    Also Check: Which Cheese Is Keto Friendly

    Storing And Reheating Leftover Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

    • If you happen to have leftovers, no worries! Grilled cheese sandwiches are melty, but not moist, which means you can place them in baggies and refrigerate for up to 2 days.
    • Reheat the sandwiches in a skillet with a little melted butter, until the cheese is melted again, or toast them in a toaster oven until heated through.

    Do You Use Mayo Or Butter For Grilled Cheese

    But it makes perfect sense when you think about the ingredients used to make mayonnaisethat creamy texture comes from whipping egg yolks and oil. Using mayo instead of butter to make grilled cheese results in a rich, golden brown exterior, and some say the taste is even better than butter!

    Read Also: How To Make Simple Cheese Dip

    Best Grilled Cheese Bread

    Sliced white bread is a go-to, but subbing in different breads can lend your grilled cheese more flavor and texture. Try a sturdy sourdough, multi-grain loaf, fluffy potato bread or brioche, or dabble in sweet-savory territory by employing a sweet bread, such as challah or cinnamon-raisin. Avoid airy breads like hole-y sourdough or focaccia, or else your cheese will seep through the bread and possibly burn in the pan.

    Armando Rafael

    Can You Use Light Mayo For Grilled Cheese

    This Grilled Cheese Hack Uses Mayo as a Secret Ingredient
  • How do you make a grilled cheese not soggy?
  • After seeing the hype about mayo on grilled cheese, I gave it a try. Mayo will give a crunchier toast-like bread, but some prefer butter for the flavor. Light mayo has more water, so the bread may not crisp up as much, but itll still crisp up more than if you used butter.

    Also Check: Is Cottage Cheese A Probiotic For Dogs

    How To Prepare Grilled Cheese In A Microwave

  • 1Toast the bread in a toaster so it gets crispy. Put 2 slices of the bread you want to use in your toaster and cook them for about 3-4 minutes or until theyre golden brown. Pull the bread out of your toaster once its finished so you can use it for your sandwich.XResearch source
  • You dont have to toast the bread if you dont want to, but your sandwich wont be crispy.
  • 2Put 1-2 slices of cheese between the pieces of bread. Choose your favorite kind of cheese to use for your sandwich. Set 1-2 thin slices of cheese on top of one of your pieces of bread, and then set the second piece on top to make your sandwich.XResearch source
  • American cheese will melt the easiest in your microwave, but any cheese will work for your sandwich.
  • 3Wrap the sandwich in a paper towel so the cheese melts better. Set the sandwich on a piece of paper towel and wrap it up completely. The paper towel will help trap the heat so the cheese melts faster without making your bread soggy. Set the wrapped sandwich on a plate so its ready to cook.XResearch source
  • 4Cook the sandwich in the microwave for 15-20 seconds or until the cheese melts. Set the sandwich in the middle of the microwave and run it in 15-20 increments. When the microwaves finished running, unwrap your sandwich and check if the cheese has melted. If not, put it back in your microwave for another 15 seconds. Otherwise, unwrap your sandwich completely and serve it.XResearch source
  • The bread may get soggier the longer its in the microwave.
  • The Best Grilled Cheese Recipe Ever

    We all love a good grilled cheese sandwich, right? But, have you ever made an epic grilled cheese on the stove at home? You know, the kind with a cheese pull for miles and crispy, perfectly golden brown edges of buttery brilliance. Sometimes you nail it, sometimes you burn it, or it comes out a little dry, or the cheese isnt fully melted. Well, were here to teach you how to make the best grilled cheese everno more disappointments! Just melted cheese sandwich perfection, for the rest of your grilled cheese-filled days.

    Recommended Reading: How To Cook Annie’s Mac And Cheese

    Your Question: Does Grilled Cheese Taste Better With Mayo

  • What are good things to grill?
  • But it makes perfect sense when you think about the ingredients used to make mayonnaisethat creamy texture comes from whipping egg yolks and oil. Using mayo instead of butter to make grilled cheese results in a rich, golden brown exterior, and some say the taste is even better than butter!

    What Can I Add To Grilled Cheese To Make It Better

    Finding The Best Way To Make A Grilled Cheese

    To add a ton of flavor to a simple grilled cheese, adding ingredients like chutney, pepper jelly, tomato jam, or bacon jam can totally change the flavor profile. Any jam, any chutney, even dijon mustard, almost any condiment will lend itself to a grilled cheese sandwich, Werlin said.

    Dont Miss: What Is The Biggest Traeger Grill

    Also Check: How To Make Cheese Sticks

    Follow Your Heart Smoked Gouda Slices

    As someone who first started eating vegan cheese 30 years ago, I can say both variety and quality have improved drastically, said Anya Todd, a dietitian specializing in vegan nutrition. That said, Follow Your Heart has been around since 1970, and their vegan cheese slices are still one of my faves. They melt and stretch, which is exactly what I want in a grilled cheese sammich!

    Vora also endorsed Follow Your Heart, specifically the smoked gouda flavor.

    For a more nontraditional grilled cheese, the Follow Your Heart Smoked Gouda Slices are a great option, she said. It has more of a smoky flavor but still melts really well.

    Dont Miss: Grease Off Concrete

    How To Make Grilled Cheese In A Toaster

  • 1Turn your toaster on its side so you can slide bread in horizontally. The cheese wont melt on your bread if the toasters still upright while you cook it. Carefully tilt your toaster on its side so the slots face horizontally rather than vertically. That way, the cheese will melt on top of the bread without falling off.XResearch source
  • If you cant turn your toaster sideways, you can purchase toaster bags online to make your sandwich while the toasters still upright.
  • 2Put slices of bread with 1 slice of cheese each into the slots on your toaster. Set a piece of cheese on each of your bread slices before you put them in the toaster. Carefully slide the bread and cheese sideways into the slots of the toaster. Make sure the cheese doesnt fall off the bread when you insert it.XResearch source
  • Dont use bread thats too thick since it may not fit in your toaster.
  • American cheese will melt the best in your toaster, but you can use any type of cheese.
  • Warning: Check that the cheese doesnt hang over the sides of the bread slices since it could drip inside your toaster and create a fire hazard.

  • 3Toast the bread and cheese for 3-4 minutes before unplugging your toaster. Set your toaster to cook for about 5 minutes and pull the lever down to start toasting your sandwich. After 3-4 minutes, unplug your toaster so it doesnt pop, or else it may shoot your bread onto your counter and make a mess.XResearch source
  • Keep any leftovers sealed in the fridge for up to a week.
  • Read Also: Where Can I Buy Goat Cheese

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This