What Is The Best Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Don't Miss

The Best Cheeses To Use For Mac And Cheese

Our Taste Test of Sharp Cheddar Cheese

The type of cheese you use can make or break your mac and cheese sauce.

Armando Rafael

Take a moment to think about the best mac and cheese youve ever had. Perhaps youd describe it as ooey-gooey, creamy or cheesy. At its worst, mac and cheese is grainy, stringy or greasy. The type of cheese you use can make or break your sauce. But perhaps the name itself is a misnomer. The ideal mac and cheese needs more than one kind of cheese.

When youre cruising down the cheese aisle, two factors to consider are meltability and flavor. Generally, young and processed cheeses melt smoothly but taste bland when theyre mixed with a few pounds of pasta. Aged and funky blocks are tricky melters but add a lot of complex cheese flavor to the dish. This dichotomy explains why mac and cheese recipes often call for not one, but several types of cheese.

But there is one go-to that you’ll almost always see. An overview of Food Networks mac and cheese roundup reveals that most recipes have one type of cheese in common: sharp Cheddar. Sharp Cheddar especially the inexpensive, mass-market block you can buy at the supermarket strikes just the right balance between meltability and flavor. Consider it your base cheese. If you dont want to buy three different types of cheese and rack up the grocery bill, its completely fine to use Cheddar on its own. Just stay away from the pre-shredded kind, which often contains additives like cornstarch that interfere with silky melting.

Cooking With Cheddar Cheese

Most cheddar cheese is great to cook with. It is what people typically use when they make a grilled cheese sandwich or macaroni and cheese. Some cheeses, however, such as extra-sharp cheddar are best left to marinate in their natural juices before being added to dishes.

You often do get some greasiness when you add cheddar to the top of a dish. If this happens, gently lie a piece of kitchen towel over the top to soak it up.

What You Need To Know

American cheddar consumption has nearly doubled since 1970, and supermarket shelves are bursting with options, which makes choosing the best block a daunting task. Cheddar comes in a number of stylesmild, sharp, extra sharp, and more. These terms arent regulated by the United States Food and Drug Administration , but they usually indicate how long a cheese has been aged. Typi… read more

Read Also: Can You Put Sour Cream In Mac And Cheese

Difference Between ‘mild”sharp’ And ‘extra Sharp


147 People Used

How To Make Vegan Sharp cheddar Cheese Recipe How To…
How A 100-Year-Old Vermont Creamery Makes Cheddar…
How To Make Sirloin Sliders with Sharp Cheddar Cheese…
Here’s the difference between mild, sharp, and extra…

Sharp Cheddar Vs Mild Cheddar

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Aged 4 Years

Sharp cheddar is considered to attain the classical cheese taste, throughout the world, while mild cheese is one of the somewhat less tangy and sharp in taste, also liked by some sweet lovers.

Sharp cheddar has found its name from the time it is aged for about 12 to 24 months gets sharp classical taste on the other hand, mild cheddar has found its name due to mild sharp taste with the slightly sweet flavor and from the time it is aged for about 2 to 3 months. Sharp cheddar is tasted by the bitterness of peptides of protein in the cheese as their level is increased with age by the enzymes breaking down proteins on the flip side of the coin, mild cheese is less sharp and tangy because of less age time.

Sharp cheddar has low moisture content with crumbly texture on the other side, mild cheddar has high moisture content with a smooth texture. Sharp cheddar is difficult to melt because of dry nature, whereas mild cheddar is easy to melt because of high moisture content. The nutritional content of the sharp cheddar cheese is about 110 calories with 9g fat content and 7g protein content, whereas the nutritional content of the mild cheddar cheese is about 70 calories with 6g fat content and 4g protein content.

Also Check: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

What Is The Purpose Of A Comparison Site

When you search for a product on the Internet, you can compare all the offers that are available from the sellers. However, it can take time when it is necessary to open all the pages, compare the opinions of the Internet users, the characteristics of the products, the prices of the different models Offering you reliable comparisons allows us to offer you a certain time saving and a great ease of use. Shopping on the Internet is no longer a chore, but a real pleasure! We do everything we can to offer you relevant comparisons, based on various criteria and constantly updated. The product you are looking for is probably among these pages. A few clicks will allow you to make a fair and relevant choice. Dont be disappointed with your purchases made on the Internet and compare the best Powdered Cheese now!

How Does Shredded Cheddar Compare To Block Cheddar

But how did our favorite preshredded cheddar compare to our favorite supermarket sharp cheddar cheese that we shredded ourselves? To find out, we pitted it against shreds of our favorite block cheddar, Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar, in three more blind tastings: plain, on nachos, and in Simple Stovetop Macaroni and Cheese.

In the plain tasting, the Cabot block cheese won by a landslide. Its shreds had a much sharper, more prominent, and punchy flavor, without any of the starchiness of the Kraft cheddar. Though flavor differences mellowed out when the two cheeses were melted, tasters also preferred the silky texture of the Cabot cheese in nachos. The Kraft cheese, which had the smoothest texture of all the preshredded cheeses we tried, didnt break and wasnt overly greasy however, it was still dry when compared with the block cheese, likely due to the addition of modified cornstarch. As we expected, experts confirmed that the cellulose and starches added to preshredded cheeses dry out the surface of the shreds and inhibit melting and flow.

So when should you opt for preshredded cheese? If you have the time, we still recommend shredding block cheese by hand or in a food processor for the best results. However, for dishes where the cheese will be melted or combined with other ingredients, we think the shredded stuff makes a perfectly acceptable shortcut.

Also Check: What Sauce Is On Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

Organic Valley Raw Sharp Cheddar

This cheese falls in line with the nutrition of other cheeses on this list, but it stands out because of its “raw” label. It’s important to clarify the difference between raw milk and raw milk cheese. Raw milk has not been pasteurized to kill off the good or bad bacteria, so drinking raw milk is dicey. However, when it comes to making raw cheese, the microorganisms in raw milk are a welcome taste and aroma variable for cheesemakers. In the US, cheese made from raw milk has to be aged for at least 60 days to decrease the risk of pathogens, and cheesemakers are required to follow specific FDA food safety protocols and conduct testing throughout the production process. Those who are immunocompromised in any way should probably skip the raw cheese options like this one.

RELATED: Your ultimate restaurant and supermarket survival guide is here!

Types Of Cheddar Cheese

Easy Cheese Sharp Cheddar Spray Cheese vs. Walmart Great Value Cheese Wow Spread FoodFights Review

There are two main types of cheddar cheese: sharp cheddar and mild cheddar.

Sharp Cheddar Cheese This variety is aged for a longer period of time which gives it a stronger taste and saltier bite. Its texture resembles that of parmesan cheese but its consistency is rougher due to more air being blown into the cheese during production. This variant, also known as extra sharp cheddar, is what you typically use for cooking.

Mild Cheddar Cheese Mild cheddar cheese is what you typically want to add in a sandwich or add to a recipe. It is what most people think of when they hear the word cheddar it is what you get in your grilled cheese sandwich from a diner, what you get when you order a cheeseburger at McDonalds and what you put on your macaroni and cheese from the cafeteria. It is milder in taste, smoother in texture and far less expensive than its sharper cousin, extra sharp cheddar.

Recommended Reading: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

Make Awesome Baked Macaroni And Cheese With These Recipes + Tipsyour Browser Indicates If You’ve Visited This Link

They used tomatoes a lot, so a variety of the baked macaroni we know today combines these essential ingredients: pasta, meat, tomato sauce, cream sauce, and cheese. This cheesy ultimate comfort food that has the power to turn a frown into a smile is the iconic baked macaroni and cheese.


Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar

Cabot’s sharp cheddar has the same simple ingredients as other cheeses in this lineup. But the brand itself holds “Best in Class” awards for several of their cheeses from national and international cheese competitions, which attests to their overall production quality. Cabot is a B corp which means they meet the highest standards for social and environmental practices, transparency, and legal accountability in creating an inclusive global economy. The company is comprised of 800 family-owned farms, so if supporting small farmers is a priority for you, this is your perfect option.

Recommended Reading: Who Invented Babybel Cheese

Looking For The Best Powdered Cheese

Discover now our comparison of the best Powdered Cheese. It is never easy to choose from the wide range of offers. On the market, you will find an incalculable number of models, all at different prices. And as you will discover, the best Powdered Cheese are not always the ones at the highest prices! Many criteria are used, and they make the richness and relevance of this comparison. To help you make the best choice among the hundreds of products available, we have decided to offer you a comparison of the Powdered Cheese in order to find the best quality/price ratio. In this ranking, you will find products listed according to their price, but also their characteristics and the opinions of other customers. Also discover our comparisons by categories. You wont have to choose your products at random anymore.

  • Perfect for sprinkling on popcorn, pretzels or any snack you want!
  • Same as our regular white cheese powder – only 2x bigger!
  • White Cheddar Cheese powder is also delicious with baked potatoes, pastas and salads
  • Hoosier Hill Farm Brand – your satisfaction is guaranteed.
  • 2 lb. White Cheddar Cheese powder in plastic jar

Cheese And Fruit Pairings

How do I Choose the Best Cheddar Cheese? (with pictures)

Fruit is a great cheese board accompaniment: you can serve a cheese platter as appetizer, with a glass of good wine, or at the end of your meal, before the dessert. with a fortified wine.

Use seasonal fruit to make a cheese board. The best Cheddar and fruit pairing ideas are: apple or pear wedges, grapes and drupes. A good cheese board has 3 to 5 different kind of cheese, fruit , bread or cracker, olives, mustards, honey and jams. Read more about how to prepare the perfect cheese board.

You May Like: Can You Put Sour Cream In Mac And Cheese

The Best Shredded Sharp Cheddar Cheese: Kraft Sharp Cheddar Shredded Natural Cheese

For quick fixes and simple weeknight meals, we recommend Kraft Sharp Cheddar Shredded Natural Cheese . It was subtly sharp and savory, and when melted it had the smoothest texture of all the products we tried.

If you have the time to shred your own cheese, our favorite supermarket sharp cheddar cheese is Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar . Its flavor is punchier and it melts better than our preshredded favorite from Kraft.

Which Cheddar Cheese Is Best

Cheese! A food so good that you can put it on almost any other food and it makes that food better! Dont believe me? My multiple lactose intolerant friends who wont stop eating cheese say otherwise. When we were asked to hold a Cheddar Cheese taste test, we knew it was a must!

The person who asked us to test Cheddar Cheese felt overwhelmed at the amount of brands of cheese, and the wide range of prices. And its true, there is such a wide range. Look at the price difference between the cheapest contender and the most expensive contender below.

Setting up the Cheddar Cheese Taste Test

The cheeses were presented on identical plates, labeled A-F.

The panelists were asked to select them all at once and were allowed to test in whatever order they wanted.

Panelists were able to eat the cheese alone, or with whatever food they wanted to eat with it. However they had to stick with that food for each brand. To see how we keep all tests unbiased, as well as a list of every test ever, click here.

Read Also: Sour Cream Or Cream Cheese In Mac And Cheese

Great Value Medium Cheddar

Walmart’s generic brand cheddar is nearly identical in terms of the nutrition facts and ingredient list to the cheddar sold under Whole Foods’ generic brand 365. However, because it’s not a sharp cheddar, you may need more of it to feel that same cheesy satisfaction. If sourcing and ingredient specifics aren’t too important to you, this cheddar is a good, honest block of “what you see is what you get”.

Sargento Medium Cheddar Slices

Cracker Barrel vs President Sharp Cheddar – FoodFights Reviews the Best Pub Cheese Spread to Buy

With a lineup of basic ingredientsâpasteurized milk culture, salt, enzymes, and annattoâand an average amount of sodium, this Sargento sliced cheddar is a completely acceptable option if you like the convenience of having your cheese pre-sliced. Just remember that there’s typically a markup for that.

Recommended Reading: Dominos Philly Cheese Steak Pizza Recipe

Our Very Favorite Cheddar

The Whole Foods house brand scored far and away the highest in our rankings for flavor, texture, and ideal level of saltiness. It crumbled nicely when coaxed with a cheese knife, but relaxed into a creamy, tangy delight when placed in the mouth. Among all the cheese we tasted, both our food director, Rhoda Boone, and associate food editor, Anna Stockwell, declared this one the very best cheddar cheese of the bunch.

We were pleasantly surprised by Sargento, which is only available either sliced or shredded. Despite our pre-conceived notions about pre-sliced cheese, tasters called Sargento “distinctly sharp and tangy,” and “mild but nutty in a good way.” If you’re buying for cheeseburgers and want the convenience, this just may be the best cheddar cheese for your purposes.


How We Selected The 8 Brands

I selected a variety of well-known national brands of cheddar cheese that can be found at most grocery stores across the country. I opted to stick with yellow cheddar, and stayed away from locally produced cheese. All the brands included were found from visiting three major grocery stores in New York City.

Don’t Miss: Does Babybel Melt

Cracker Barrel Sharp Cheddar Cheese

This was the cheddar cheese of my childhood, so I was curious to see how it stacked up, and if any of the taste testers recognized it from their youth. This cheddar was softer and certainly more mild-tasting than some of the others. One tasters noted that this cheese tastes processed, but I love it because it reminds me of my childhood cheese.

Blue Diamond Cheddar Cheese Almond Nut Thins

Supermarket Sharp Cheddar Cheese

These were too “greasy and salty,” so most people “wouldn’t want to eat more than a few.” The cheese dust didn’t exactly incorporate with the cracker, either, so it was a layer of cheese on top of an almond cracker. There was also a “dried herb taste” that will give you “SUPER ONION BREATH,” so not pure cheddar regardless. A little odd.

Read Also: What Sauce Is On Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

What Makes One Cheddar Sharper Or Milder Than Another And What Are The Different Sharp Cheese Types

All Cabot cheddars are naturally aged, which imparts the signature bite that makes them the worlds best. As cheddar ages, it loses moisture, which concentrates and intensifies the sharpness. So, in general, the sharper the cheddarthe longer its been aged. Use our Sharpness Scale to help you choose the right level of sharpness every time.

Cabot Sharp Light Natural Vermont Cheddar 50% Reduced Fat

Clearly we think Cabot’s doing something right, so what sets this specific cheese apart? Well it’s a reduced fat cheddar, which means it’s specifically made with low-fat milk to provide half the amount of fat as the standard cheddar cheese. Coming in at 70 calories per ounce instead of 110, and 4 grams of fat instead of 9, this may be your pick for a high quality, responsibly-made cheese, if you’re keeping a close eye on the calorie and fat count. The addition you may notice on the ingredient list here is vitamin A palmitate. Per Cabot’s website, this is a substance naturally found in milk, but lost when the fat content is reduced. The law mandates the addition of vitamin A to such products, and the term “palmitate” is associated with a fatty acid from plants which helps the vitamin A remain stable. Nothing sketchy here!

Don’t Miss: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

The Most Common Use For Cheddar Is In The Cheeseburger But There Are A Lot Of Things To Make With Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar is the most famous Anglo-Saxon cheese. It first appeared on the English tables of a small village in Somerset, at the end of the 12th century. This village was called Cheddar.

The United States Department of Agriculture affirms that Cheddar is the most famous cheese in the world.

A Cheddar wheel has a cylindrical shape and can be found in a big variety of sizes: from 12 to 130 pounds. Mild Cheddar is white and has a sweet taste. Sharp Cheddar is an aged cheese, with a golden color and a piquant taste. The orange one is a variety colored with Annatto seeds. Sometimes you can find it covered by a characteristic layer of red wax.

But, how to use Cheddar cheese in cooking?

The most common use for Cheddar is in cheeseburger, but there are a lot of things to make with Cheddar cheese. In the UK, for example, Cheddar is often served at the end of the meal, with fresh fruit, bread and butter. In USA the common uses of Cheddar cheese are: Macaroni Cheese, Cheese Straws and Baked potatoes.

Cheddar is also used in Mexican recipes, like Tacos and spicy Tortillas with beef and beans. In Cheese Pie Italian recipe Cheddar can substitute Fontina.

Popular Articles

More Recipes Like This