What Is The Best Boxed Mac And Cheese

Don't Miss

Replace Half Of The Butter With American Cheese

The Best Tricks To Make Boxed Mac And Cheese Taste Even Better

My third trick is to replace half of the butter with two or three slices of American cheese. The difference is incredible!

The instructions say to use four tablespoons of butter . Were only going to use two, plus some American cheese.

I get my American cheese sliced really thick, so two of my slices would be equal to about three slices of packaged stuff. But hey, go ahead and throw in a fourth if you want. It will just be even creamier and cheesier!

Can you use all of the butter the instructions call for, plus the American cheese? Sure, but I actually like it better this way. It gets a little too greasy with all that butter added to the extra cheese.

How To Make Box Mac And Cheese Better

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

We are obsessed with box mac and cheese . Have you ever wondered how to make box mac and cheese better? This is our go-to way to make box mac and cheese. Its so creamy and flavorful youll never go back to the boring way!

We Ate 122 Boxes Of Mac And Cheese From Grocery Stores And Ranked Them All

We sampled 122 types of macaroni and cheese found in grocery store and big box aisles. Which mac & cheese finished No. 1?

CLEVELAND, Ohio — Theres something decadent about the simple combination of butter, cheese and pasta. Whether youre a toddler or an octogenarian, the phrase macaroni and cheese conjures heaven in a bowl and the ultimate comfort.

Clevelands Best reporters Brenda Cain and Yadi Rodriguez have conducted more than a dozen supermarket showdown rankings of food items and when brainstorming their latest foray into the aisles of Northeast Ohio grocery and big box stores, everyone agreed — macaroni & cheese! Please!

We found 122 different varieties of boxed mac and cheese in stores around the region. Of course, we bought and sampled all of them. Prices ranged from just $0.33 to $5.99. Scroll down to see our rankings and thoughts on each macaroni & cheese. Who made the Top 10? Where did the iconic Kraft original in the dark blue box finish?

Just look at that cheese! We purchased 122 boxes of mac and cheese from local stores and ranked them all in our latest grocery store showdown.

Some highlights — and surprises:

The Cracker Barrel brand claimed two of the Top 10 spots. Walmarts Great Value label has two flavors in the Top 15.

Of the Top 15, six are made with milk and butter and include those old-school powder packets of cheese.

And who knew theres a bright red Flamin Hot Cheetos flavor?!


Also Check: What Brand Of Nacho Cheese Does Taco Bell Use

Is Annies Mac And Cheese Healthy

This frozen mac can be made in the microwave or oven, but the oven is absolutely going to be tastier and give you that homemade mac and cheese taste. This mac and cheese was not my favorite: the Amys had a more authentic cheesy flavor, while this one felt more mild, and the pasta kind of overwhelmed the cheese. It was less creamy than Id hoped but it wasnt bad, and when I doctored it up by adding some extra cheese and butter to the mix, it was actually pretty great. Of course, that kind of defeats the purpose.

Read next: 7 Clean Comfort Food Recipes You Can Make On a Weeknight

When comparing the nutrition of the other options to Annies Frozen Mac and Cheese, this brand is nutritionally a pretty great choice. This product has the lowest sodium of any mac and cheese reviewed at 550 mg per serving, provides 12 g of protein per serving, and provides 33% less fat than Amys brand, said Dillon. So it may be a really smart and healthy choice, but not necessarily the tastiest. Nobody said you were able to have your mac and cheese and eat it too, after all.

Velveeta Shells & Cheese

Best Boxed Mac &  Cheese Taste Test

Don’t let Velveeta fool youwhile this mac and cheese is made with a packet of cheese sauce, it’s not necessarily healthy by any means. From the 12 grams of fat and the ridiculously high amount of sodium, it’s best to leave this “liquid gold” on the shelf. Keep in mind this is just one serving! You’re much better off trying your hand at making your own mac and cheese from scratch.

Also Check: What Is In Taco Bell Nacho Cheese

Video Result For What To Cook With Macaroni And Cheese

Creamy Macaroni and Cheese Recipe | How to Make Mac N…
Macaroni and Cheese Recipe | How to Make Mac and Cheese
CHEESY BAKED MAC AND CHEESE | Thanksgiving Sides |…
Baked Macaroni & Cheese Recipe
BEST EVER Macaroni and Cheese Recipe – Creamy Baked…
How to make Macaroni and Cheese – Easy Cooking!
Southern Baked Macaroni & Cheese Casserole – I Heart…
Macaroni and Cheese Recipe
How to Make Easy Stovetop Mac and Cheese
Baked Macaroni and Cheese – Best with Bacon – Recipes…
Baked Mac n’ Cheese Recipe | Macaroni and Cheese
How to Make Macaroni and Cheese For One | At Home…
How to Make Delicious Macaroni and Cheese with Ham |…
Easy Stovetop Macaroni and Cheese – Creamy Mac and…
How To Make Macaroni And Cheese
Ultra Creamy Baked Mac and Cheese – How to Make the…
Holiday Series | Southern Style Macaroni & Cheese -…
Easy Baked Macaroni and Cheese Recipe with Panko Bread…
How to Make Baked Macaroni & Cheese | Secret…
My Favorite Baked Mac And Cheese | Simply Mamá Cooks
How To Make Baked Macaroni And Cheese
Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese: Easy Recipe (Fast…
Homemade Macaroni and Cheese in the Oven
How to Make Simple Stovetop Ground Beef Macaroni and…
How to Make 3-Ingredient Stovetop Macaroni and Cheese
How to Make MACARONI and CHEESE Like an Italian
Easy 3-Ingredient Mac and Cheese Recipe

Cracker Barrel Oven Baked Macaroni & Cheese Dinner

Average Price:$9.71

The Mac N Cheese:

Cracker Barrel has a wide selection of mac and cheese dinners. Theyre generally big enough to serve as a side during dinner and theyre designed to be baked. You need to fire up the oven to finish this one off and it really makes a difference.

Bottom Line:

This is better than it has any business being. Its savory, cheesy, and doesnt need a shake of salt to round out the seasoning of the sauce.

Also Check: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

Annies Macaroni And Cheese

Average Price:$1.00

The Mac N Cheese:

Annies has corned the market on bespoke, seemingly high-end mac and cheese. While this isnt intrinsically any different than Kraft or Trader Joes above, it does have an edge thanks to the taste.

Bottom Line:

Annies edges out based on the pasta alone. Theres still a cardboard essence but its almost gone and gets covered up nicely by a cheesy sauce that doesnt need another hit of salt to be well-rounded.

How To Add In Mac And Cheese Mix

This is the Best Vegan Boxed Mac and Cheese | Taste Test Bonus Ending!

My favorite way to add in these mix-ins is to cook the macaroni and cheese according to the package instructions, and then once it’s completely cooked and set for a few minutes, add in the mix-ins. I like to do it after it cooks because then I can customize each bowl to everyone’s preferences and make everyone happy.

You can add in one or more of the above mix-ins to take your mac and cheese to a whole new level!

Related Post: How to Make Mac and Cheese in the Instant Pot

Don’t Miss: Philly Cheese Steak Pizza Dominos Calories

Is Mac And Cheese Healthy

There are lots of quick and easy foods to feed kids, but probably the top of the list is mac and cheese, says Stacey Krawczyk, MS, RD. In a time crunch, I have definitely used boxed or prepared versions to feed my kids. I look at what all I am serving in that week, and try to balance out prepared foods with simple-made foods. Regardless, I always look to balance out the plate with lots of veggies and focus on portion sizes, said Krawczy.

Mac and cheese, when made with enriched grains, can provide vitamins and minerals and absolutely be part of a balanced meal. And when youre making a healthy, baked mac and cheese from scratch, you can determine exactly what goes into it. Of course, most of us dont often have the time for that kind of thing, so I spoke with some nutrition pros to help us find ways to make the boxed stuff a little better-for-you.

Annie’s Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese

Average Cheesiness: 6.5

Average Tastiness: 6.8

With a total of 13.3, Annies Cheddar just barely beat out Kraft for the winning spot. All tasters said they would choose this mac ‘n cheese again, and one even asked to take home the leftovers! And if this comfort food is too simple for you, Annies also offers a multitude of mac ‘n cheese types, including lots of fun shapes and a gluten-free option.

There it is, folks. The all-time greatest boxed macaroni is Annies Cheddar, with Kraft in a close second position. If you ever find yourself questioning which mac ‘n cheese to buy, you can be confident that Annies Cheddar cant, and won’t fail you.

Don’t Miss: What Sauce Is On Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

One Important Factor To Consider Is The Sodium

Did you know between 95% of children ages 2-13 exceed the recommended sodium limits? said Meghan Dillon, RD. Packaged goods are a huge contributor to this issue. I would compare sodium to rule out which boxes or frozen packages of mac and cheese to avoid purchasing, she says. And Id aim to choose a product with a sodium content of 675 mg per serving or less.

Modern Table Three Cheese Mac & Cheese

We Tried 7 Boxes to Find the Best Mac and Cheese

Modern Table is known for its high-protein options and this mac and cheese does deliver that.

Our protein-packed Three Cheese Mac & Cheese combines the power of plant protein with the joy of comfort food. Lentils, rice and pea protein make up our gluten-free, protein-packed mac & cheese, plus a three-cheese sauce we call the triple threat.

Also Check: Does Babybel Cheese Need Refrigeration

America’s Choice Macaroni & Cheese

“Pretty flavorless” with “mushy noodles,” but at least it was “inoffensive.” Most tasters found it to be pretty similar to the Kraft, but not quite as flavorful, and a little less creamy. Some complained of a slightly grainy texture. It lost most of its points for a mushier pasta than the Kraft it’s trying to clone.

Who Was The Winner

Okay. I put you through all that just to make you wait until here until I announce the winner. You know, wait with baited breath, type of thing! HA!

Overall we were underwhelmed with this taste test. We thought it would be much better than it was.

Now, without further ado!

Our top 3 brands would be:

  • Pastabilities Vegan Organic Mac N Cheese
  • Annies Organic Vegan Mac Shell Pasta Pumpkin and Sweet Potato Creamy Sauce
  • Modern Table Vegan Mac Classic Cheddar Style

Rounding out the top 5 would be Daiya and Uptons.

We think you will be happy with these brands.

Do you agree with us? Have you tried any of these ? Tell us below!

Want to make your own from scratch? We absolutely love our homemade 10 minute mac more than any of these boxed brands.

To make it we cook 2 cups elbow noodles to al dente. While that is cooking we make our 10 minute vegan cheese sauce. Then combine the two and serve

Also Check: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

Kraft Velveeta Shells & Cheese

Nothing has a smoother, creamier melt than Velveeta. Its called Liquid Gold, because its just that good! Krafts Velveeta Macaroni and Cheese also uses shells, so there is a great bite to the pasta and perfect creaminess to the sauce. It definitely has the best texture of any boxed macaroni and cheese we sampled to compile this list.

There may not be as many varieties of this one compared to other brands, but they do include most of the classics. They have Velveeta Original Shells & Cheese, Velveeta Shells & Cheese With 2% Milk Cheese, Velveeta Shells & Cheese Queso Blanco, and Velveeta Bacon Shells & Cheese. There is also a version with rotini pasta that has creamy Velveeta sauce and broccoli.

The main issue with Velveeta Shells & Cheese is the taste. Some people really love the iconic taste of Velveeta processed cheese and get nostalgic about it, while others feel that the overwhelming taste of processed cheese ruins what would otherwise be a nice, creamy bowl of mac and cheese.

Most of our crew preferred the real cheese flavor of the brand you are about to see in the top spot, but that doesnt diminish Velveetas Liquid Gold status!

The Worst: Great Value Original Macaroni & Cheese

Best Vegan Boxed Mac and Cheese – Taste Test!

More than one of our young taste-testers noticed right away that the Great Value Macaroni & Cheese had a weird taste, and the grown-ups had to agree. Although the expiration date on the box was almost a year away, it had a faint stale, almost freezer-burnt taste to it.

While it didnt taste any saltier than the other brands, it contained the most sodium by far 690 mg per serving! Thats over 100 mg of sodium more than any other contender in our taste test, and 30% of the recommended daily value! This was our least favorite brand of the five we tested, by unanimous decision.

Don’t Miss: Do Babybels Need To Be Refrigerated

Stouffer’s Macaroni And Cheese

Another frozen mac option that just can’t hold its own. Stouffer’s Macaroni and Cheese doesn’t cut it for us either. Is it a bit tastier than the Lean Cuisine? Yes. That might be because it’s not trying to brand itself as a health food . But it still has that floppy, weak-looking macaroni that looks less than inviting. The cheese sauce can be watery, and it’s all but sure to be flavorless. And to top it all off, you don’t even get much in a single package unless you buy a family size. Mac and cheese is about indulging, but you’re not going to be able to fill a big bowl with a normal portion of this stuff.

If you’re left with no other options and have to pick up some Stouffer’s to cure your mac and cheese craving, the least you can do is upgrade it. By adding protein, spices, and even some breadcrumbs, you may be able to save this less-than-appealing freezer meal.

Craving Comfort Food In A Hurry Enter Boxed Macaroni And Cheese We Put Seven Brands To The Test To Find The Best Mac And Cheese

Ooey, gooey, creamy and cheesy, theres no other comfort food quite like macaroni and cheese. And making that best mac and cheese from scratch? Well, thats an art. If youre like me, though, you dont always have the time to whip up a macaroni masterpiece. Thats when I turn to a regular, old box of mac and cheese to satisfy my craving for comfort food fast

Now, I have my go-to brand , but I was curious how all these other box macs stacked up. Was there really a better option out there? So along with a panel of macaroni and cheese experts, I put these brands to the test: Annies, Back to Nature, Cracker Barrel, Horizon, Kraft, Kraft Deluxe and ShurFine. Lets see how they stacked up!

Also Check: What Comes On A Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

Annie’s Organic Alfredo Shells & Cheddar Mac & Cheese

The major upside to this Annie’s option is that it’s made with real cheese from cows that aren’t treated with growth hormone rBST. Wondering what exactly that means? rBGH, aka rBST, is a genetically engineered hormone that some farmers inject into their cows to boost milk production. But what knocks it down is the sodium, as one serving will cost you 700 milligrams. The American Heart Association recommends no more than 2,300 milligrams per day.

Macaroni And Cheese Pizza

The Best Boxed Mac and Cheese Picks

Pizza + mac and cheese = the combo you never knew you needed. It’s a match made in heaven! We’re excited about this one, guys! It may sound a little weird but stick with us. This isn’t just tasty, it’s also foolproof.

If you’re looking for a simple recipe to serve as your guide, this mac-n-cheese pizza from Allrecipes is easy as pie. Pun intended!

You can make this your own by adding your favorite proteins, veggies, and sauces, so be creative! But if you’re not feeling adventurous, all you really need is an easy pizza crust recipe and some macaroni and cheese. Seriously. That’s it.

Pssst Looking for a quick and easy homemade pizza sauce? Try this one! It’s to die for.

Also Check: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

Takeaways From The Food Rankers Crew

When selecting the best macaroni and cheese brands for your family, you cant go wrong with any of the ones on our list. It all comes down to taste and preferences. For example, we found that ones with pouch of thick, cheesy sauce were more successful with all of our reviewers. It makes preparation easier and melts into a smoother, flavorful sauce compared to the powdered cheese options.

What do you think the best boxed macaroni and cheese brands are? Do you agree with our list? Let us know in the comments below!

Popular Articles

More Recipes Like This