What Is Pepper Jack Cheese Made Out Of

Don't Miss

Is Monterey Jack And Pepper Jack The Same Cheese

Homemade Pepper Jack Cheese

However, Monterey Jack and Pepper Jack are not the same cheese. The reason for that is that even though they share the same basis, Monterey Jack is simply just that, just the plain cheese with nothing added.

On the other hand, Pepper Jack is made by mixing the original Monterey Jack with some additional flavors usually sweet peppers, some herbs, garlic, and jalapeñso. Every Pepper Jack recipe is a little bit different, though, so this may vary a bit.

Monterey Jack Cheese Recipes

The Monterey Jack cheese taste is slightly mild, making it a perfect cheese to be used in line-up of tasty meals. Here is some inspiration that I am sure you will love:

  • Aussie Chicken with Mushrooms, Bacon, and Monterey Jack Cheese: This is a taste explosion waiting to happen in your mouth. The dish is cooked in a honey-mustard sauce so you know the taste experience will be fun paired with the Monterey Jack.
  • Haddock Au Gratin is another of my favorite Monterey Jack cheese recipes. The fish in cream sauce and Jack cheese can only be described using two words, seductively flavorful.
  • Other suggestions you can try are Enchilada Lasagna, Monterey Chicken tortilla casserole and some delightful Jack cheese and chive cornbread.

Types Of Spicy Cheese

One of the many reasons people love cheese is that it pairs well with so many other foods.

Whether you are drinking wine or making an incredible mac and cheese dish, you have tons of options when it comes to cheeses to use.

Sometimes a spicy cheese can truly shine while cooking or when tasting as well.

If you enjoy spicy cheese, you are in the right place.

Here is a list of eleven spicy cheeses you are going to want to try out today!

We had to include pepper jack cheese at the top of our list.

If you are a cheese lover, you have probably had pepper jack at some point in your life.

This cheese is a blend of Monterey jack cheese with a mix of peppers and spices.

Each pepper jack you try will probably be slightly different, but they all will have a similar characteristic of a smooth base cheese with a kick of spice.

Pepper jack cheese can be eaten on its own as it is not painfully spicy, but it makes a great grilled cheese or nacho as well.

We love how easy it is to find Pepper Jack, and it can be fun to taste the different varieties that are on the market.

Some will undoubtedly be spicier than others.

Another great feature of the pepper jack cheese is that it is moderately priced.

Most of the time, you can get pepper jack for the same price you can get a cheddar or mozzarella.

Some of the fancier flavored cheeses will start to get quite expensive.

Don’t Miss: What Is Chuck E Cheese Middle Name

Form Curd Salt & Add Pepper

The dry curds can now be transferred to a colander or draining pan where they should be allowed to drain for a few minutes with a gentle stirring.

Add Salt while still in the draining colander as soon as the curds have drained well. Your final cheese weight should be about 2.5-2.75lbs. Adding 2.5% salt to this would be just about 1 oz. of salt. Add this in 2-3 doses and stir in until it absorbed by the curd.

If making one single cheese, you can add the pepper directly to the drained and salted curds and stir well before transferring to the cloth lined molds.

Here I am making two cheeses with different peppers , so I drain the curds first and then add to the molds in layers for each separate form. I mix the additions in well as I go. In either case make sure the additions are mixed evenly into the cheese.

Dont Miss: Babybel Refrigeration

Best Pepper Jack Cheese Substitutes

Kraft Pepper Jack Medium Shredded Cheese, 8 oz Bag

This article may contain affiliate links and if you make a purchase after clicking on a link, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Pepper jack cheese is a type or variant of Monterey jack cheese that contains various kinds of spices, herbs, and even peppers incorporated into the cheese as it is forming.

Pepper jack cheese could require to be substituted for different reasons, and the good thing is that there are a few other kinds of cheese you can use to replace pepper jack cheese.

Some of the best pepper jack cheese substitutes include Gauda cheese, Havarti cheese, cheddar cheese, edam cheese, parmesan, etc.

In this article, you will get to understand what pepper jack cheese is and what you can use as an alternative whenever the need arises.

Lets get started!

Recommended Reading: Where To Buy Shredded American Cheese

Might Be Acceptable For People With Lactose Intolerance

Pepper jack cheese is made of cows milk. Lactose is a sugar found in cows milk, but pepper jack is low-carbmost or all of the lactose is taken out during the production of the cheese. Some people who are lactose intolerance can eat low-carb cheeses with little to no side effects that they usually experience from dairy products with a higher carbohydrate content.

How To Make Sliceable Cheese

  • Chop up 1/3 cup of red peppers and 1-2 Jalanos into very small pieces.
  • Saute the peppers in 1 tbsp of oil over low heat for about 3 minutes.
  • Add a can of coconut milk, 1/2 cup of water, 3 tbsp of nutritional yeast, 2 tbsp agar agar powder, 1/2 tsp garlic, 1/2 tsp lemon juice, 1 tsp salt, and a dash of cayenne pepper.
  • Heat the cheese sauce over medium heat until it begins to boil.
  • Turn down the heat until it is just barely bubbling and allow it to boil for 6 minutes while stirring frequently.
  • Pour into a glass container and allow to cool uncovered in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours.
  • Read Also: How To Make Homemade Mac & Cheese

    Spicy Chicken And Pepper Jack Pizza

    I warned you yesterday when I posted No Knead Pizza Dough that I am officially on a flatbread kick. My mind has been consumed with all the delicious combinations I can put on top of that wonderful dough to knock it out of the park and this first recipe is no exception. Spicy Chicken and Pepper Jack pizza made with Sargento Pepper Jack cheese is the perfect flatbread pizza for game night its a real guy pleaser, and a Jamie pleaser too.

    Brian tells me theres some sort of NBA final coming soon. I wouldnt know, because I dont really follow sports. But I know enough to know that hell be begging me to make these for him and his buddies while they watch the game.

    Im feeling pretty prepared for that now, with the dough recipe I shared and my constant lust for different kinds of cheese. If you looked in my fridge right now, youd see everything from Feta to Dubliner. Im pretty much prepared for any cheesy recipe that strikes my fancy. So when Sargento Cheese asked me to partner up with them on some cheese-loving recipes, I didnt have to think twice. I scoured their extensive recipe collection and stumbled upon Thin Crust Pepper Jack Pizza.

    My idea of pizza heaven cheezy, spicy, saucy. I headed to the market to pick up a few items including Sargento Shredded Pepper Jack Cheese.

    Disclosure: This post is sponsored by Sargento however, the opinions expressed are my own.

    Read Also: What Sauce Is On Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

    The 5 Best Substitutes For Pepper Jack Cheese

    Pepper Jack Mac and Cheese Recipe Must try

    What is the best cheese for nachos? If youre looking for a cheese that packs a flavorful punch, youll want to try pepper jack cheese.

    Named for the spicy peppers added to the milk during the cheesemaking process, pepper jack cheese is a delicious addition to any meal.

    However, if youre not a fan of spicy food, or if youre simply out of pepper jack cheese, several other kinds of cheese make great substitutes.

    Here are five of the best substitutes for pepper jack cheese.

    You May Like: What Cheese Is Keto Friendly

    What’s The Difference Between Monterey Jack Pepper Jack Cheddar Jack And Colby Jack

    The other day, I found myself standing in the dairy aisle staring at the variety of cheese selections and scratching my head. I was shopping for a recipe that called for Colby Jack cheese, which is a cheese I would never seek out myself, but as I sorted through all the different cheeses on the shelves, it dawned on me just how many “Jack” cheeses there are. This realization caused me to immediately spiral what is the difference between Colby Jack and the other “Jack” cheeses? Is pepper Jack just a spicy version of other Jack cheeses? What is Monterey Jack cheese and what sets it apart from the others? And seriously, who is Jack!?! This yearning for Jack truths led me on a Google search that uncovered some pretty fascinating origins of these cheeses.

    Related: What Is the Difference Between Parmesan and Parmigiano-Reggiano?

    So, what’s with all the cross-breeding? Well, all of these cheeses melt super easily, making them the perfect product to play around with and create subtle variations. Monterey Jack is a great baseline cheese because it’s mild in flavor, so by mixing it up with peppers and/or sharper cheeses, it makes for a more exciting product. There you have it. Dairy aisle existential crisis has been averted.

    Pepper Jack Cheese Recipe Ingredients

    2 gallons of milk

    1 packet of mesophilic cheese culture I get mine here

    1/2 tsp regular strength liquid rennet, dissolved in 1/2 cup of cool filtered water

    1 Tbsp sea salt

    1 3/4 tsp 2 3/4 tsp total of dried coarsely ground peppers of your choice. I picked the peppers I wanted to use, then put them into a coffee grinder to grind them up.

    Also Check: Is Chuck E Cheese Going Out Of Business

    Form The Curd Salt And Add The Pepper

    Transfer the dry curd to the colander so that it drains for a few minutes as you stir. After draining, add salt while the curds are in the colander in two to three doses and then stir properly until its well absorbed by the curd. Add the pepper directly if youre making one single cheese, stir and transfer to the molds that are cloth lined. If youre making two cheeses, separate into the molds first then add the pepper into the cheese.

    Spicy Pepper Jack Mac And Cheese

    Kraft Shredded Pepper Jack Cheese, 8 oz Bag

    This Spicy Pepper Jack Mac and Cheese recipe is a fun twist on the original, but still made in less than 15 minutes! With standard macaroni and cheese ingredients and the addition of tomatoes, jalapeno and pepper jack cheese for a kick! This is sure to be a crowd favorite!

    Love cheesy pasta? Then youve got to try my Lasagna Roll-Ups and my Spinach and Ricotta Stuffed Shells!

    Read Also: Can You Eat Unlimited Cheese On Keto

    Vegan Pepper Jack Cheese

    A perfectly rich, creamy, and spicy vegan pepper jack cheese. A simple cheese recipe that’s easy to whip up in about 10 minutes. Slice it up and serve it on crackers or add it to a vegan cheeseboard. Melt it over corn chips to make unbelievable vegan loaded nachos, use it in quesadillas, or for a spicy vegan grilled cheese.

    How Is Pepper Jack Cheese Made

    Monterey Jack Cheese was made by the Mexican Franciscan friars of Monterey, California, in the 19th century. Then David Jack, a California businessman, decided that the market for the cheese could be developed. He produced the mild, white cheese that we now call Monterey Jack. Later, producers began to add small pieces of spicy peppers to the curds of their Jack cheese, creating Pepper Jack Cheese.

    Don’t Miss: How Long Do You Microwave Mac And Cheese

    Why You’ll Love This Recipe

    • quick, easy, and simple to make.
    • filled red and green peppers for a pretty cheese platter.
    • bursting with flavor and you can adjust the spiciness.
    • gluten-free, soy-free, and cashew-free, so everyone can enjoy it.

    You can adjust this recipe to be made with coconut milk, cashews, or plant-based milk and choose to make it firm or soft and meltable.

    Monterey Jack Vs Pepper Jack: Same Cheese


    Cheese is an extremely popular dairy product that plays a crucial role in nearly every cuisine around the globe. Cheese is praised even by vegetarians, and it is simply a challenging task to find someone who wouldnt love it.

    Not every cheese is enjoyed by everyone, though, since there are countless cheese types. Two of the most popular of these are Monterey Jack and Pepper Jack.

    Because those two kinds of cheese not only look sort of similar but also share half of their names, many people think theyre the same. But thats not true. Well, at least not entirely.

    So what is the difference between Monterey Jack and Pepper Jack? The difference between Monterey Jack and Pepper Jack is that the latter is made by by adding sweet peppers and some other ingredients to the former.

    But what are those ingredients? And what does that mean for your cooking? Dont worry the answers to your questions are coming soon. So what are we waiting for? Lets jump right into it!

    You May Like: Laughing Cow Cheese Refrigerate

    Recommended Reading: What Is Mac N Cheese Made Of

    What Kind Of Cheese Is Used To Make Pepper Jack

    Monterey Jack cheesePepper jack cheese is a variant of Monterey Jack cheese. Pepper jack cheese is a semi-soft cheese with an open texture and spicy flavor from the sweet peppers, rosemary, habañero chilies, garlic, and spicy jalapeños studded in the cheese. Pepper jack melts easily, thanks to high moisture content.

    What Is The Most Delicious Cheese In The World

    MADISON: A gruyere from Switzerland has been named the worlds best cheese, chosen from a record number of entrants from 26 nations in the World Championship Cheese Contest in Wisconsin. The cheese from Bern, Switzerland made its maker, Michael Spycher of Mountain Dairy Fritzenhaus, a two-time winner.

    Read Also: Where To Buy Cheese Curds

    Don’t Miss: What Is Macaroni And Cheese

    Cut The Curd And Stir It

    Once the curd is good enough, start separating the solids and the liquids. Cut it vertically in a checkerboard pattern for the cheese then allow it to rest for three to five minutes until the whey starts rising and floods the surface. This ensures the fresh cut surfaces become firm enough making them more resistant to breakage when you start making the horizontal cuts into the curd.

    Using either a spoon or ladle start making the horizontal cuts. Make sure the final curds are about a half an inch in the end. Allow them to settle for about three to five inches so that theyre firm enough then start stirring gently from bottom to the top so that the curds remain moving and stay separated.

    Keep in mind that at this moment they are fragile. As they keep moving in the warm whey, set the temperature back to 88F in case theres a temperature drop and keep stirring for another ten minutes.

    Dont Miss: Does String Cheese Go Bad If Not Refrigerated

    What Is Monterey Jack

    Sargento® Sliced Pepper Jack Natural Cheese, 24 slices

    This mild, meltable cheese originated when Franciscan monks brought their recipe for queso del pais, a fresh, white cheese, to Californias Monterey County in the 18th century. Commercial production of Monterey Jack began in the 1850s and is often attributed to Scottish immigrant David Jacks, who marketed the product as Jacks Cheese. By the 1880s, Jacks had 14 dairy farms across California producing the cheese. Today, Wisconsin is also a significant producer of this style of cheese.

    At the start of World War I, imported Italian cheeses were no longer available in the United States. In response, cheese purveyor D.F. DiBernardi developed the recipe for Dry Jack to act as a substitute for hard, flavorful grating cheeses such as Parmesan and Grana Padano.

    Also Check: How Do You Cut Gouda Cheese

    Why Add Peppers To Cheese

    Yes, why add peppers. Well I could just say that we do it because the Italians have been doing this forever but there is a real reason why they work so well.

    Peppers in general have a strong spicy flavor often referred to as ‘picante’. This is due to a compound group that causes a ‘thermogenic’ effect. This means that they increase the body temperature and thus increase your metabolism .

    In hot peppers this is the naturally occurring ‘capsaicin’ and in black pepper it is ‘piperine’.

    Three of the most important qualities associated with the use of peppers in cheese are that:

    • These compounds are easily soluble in the fat of cheese and thus disipate the heat of the peppers so that the flavor of the pepper can shine through. They are not soluble in the water phase.
    • Cheese contains casein which tends to bind to capsaicin and relieves the heat sensors. This also promotes the focus on flavor from the peppers and lessens the heat effect.
    • They are both antimicrobial and antifungal and tend to inhibit growth both inside and on the surface of cheese.

    If you have ever tackled that super hot habanera sauce that your friends challenged you to,someone may have offered you a glass of milk as your face turned that third shade of red… Yes, it was the fat and protein in the milk that took the heat away.

    If you recall, about a year ago I made the cheese ball rolled in black pepper , I still have one of those aging in my cave and still nothing grows on the surface.

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This