Where To Buy American Cheese Block

Don't Miss

Horizon Organic American Singles

Buy Velveeta or Cheaper Walmart Brand Cheese Block Substitute? Taste Test Comparison and Review

I always want to like the organic, “better quality” option in these taste testsnot to validate my own palate, but because I want so badly for food manufacturer marketing to live up to its advertised promises. I want to not feel bamboozled by health halos and instead, be delighted by a real one. So my expectations for Horizon Organicone of the leaders in pioneering organic dairy, a partner in the creation of the USDA’s national programwere high.

Unfortunately, they did not meet them, no thanks to a new recipe released just earlier this year. And apparently, I wasn’t the only one let downit earned less than 1.5 stars on their own website by users begging for the old recipe back.

Cold, this is a harder, stiffer cheese than its competitors. It bites like a thin-sliced cheddar, but without the sharp, distinctive flavoror much flavor at all, really. It had barely any salt, but then left a vaguely milky aftertaste that wasn’t there while you were powering through the dry bite. This was also the poorest melter of the batch. When left to do so on its own, it ended with a chalky granularity akin to shredded cheeses cut with too much dehydrating cellulose. It was stubbornly slow to melt until nuked too, which revealed some creaminess and mildly warm flavor. But like a carrot on a stick, this pleasure was quickly taken away as it cooled quickly, drying out fast into a waxy coat far from ideal.

How We Graded Them

We tested these American cheese . . . er, foods two ways: As a cold slice by itself to assess its truest flavor and melted over microwaved bagged broccoli.

Why broccoli?

First of all, because it’s delicious and nutritious! But for scientific reasons, because simultaneous steam melting is a fairer gauge for a test than a grilled cheese, which offers extended exposure to higher heat. This would give some cheeses an unfair advantage and a false sense of how much heat and time they really need to melt down. Furthermore, steaming American cheese is a good way to encourage the water to separate from the singles, which helps determine which ones retain a richer flavor in their melted state. Lastly, we microwaved the whole thing to see how the cheese would melt or react over time and concentration.

Without further ado, here are American cheese slices, ranked from the just OK to the best option.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Best For Gifting: Harry & David

Courtesy of Harry & David

  • A gift for just about every occasion

  • Choose from crowd-pleasing favorites or artisanal selections

  • Cant customize gifts

A curated basket from Harry & David feels like the pinnacle of thoughtful gift-giving, and the cheese selection is no exception. The company goes beyond the average curation with fun creations, like the Football Sausage and Cheese gift box, featuring an all-beef football-shaped sausage.

Browse boxes by sought-after American cheesemakers, like Rogue Creamery, Beehive Cheese, and Sartori Cheese. Theres a California creameries collection, an organic cheese box, and even cheese and wine pairing boxes. While there are certainly deluxe options, there are also plenty of affordable boxes, too.

Recommended Reading: Can I Rent Out Chuck E Cheese

What Do You Look For When Buying Cheese Online


In general, cheesemongers will advise you to order less cheese more often, rather than stocking up, but sometimes we go overboard. Should you be buying in bulk, make sure to eat softer cheeses, like Brie and burrata, first. The harder cheeses, like parmesan and cheddar, can last months in your fridge as opposed to a few weeks for the softer stuff.


Your cheese will likely come packaged in butcher paperand thats where it should remain. Plastic wrap will suffocate cheese and impart unpleasant flavors.


Many shops offer assortment boxes that make a lovely cheese plate. Should you be curating your own cheese board selection, stick to a range of milk types and textures. An old cheesemonger saying is something old , something new , something stinky, something blue.

American Cheese: Everything You Need To Know

Bongards 5 lb. Solid Block Yellow American Cheese

Forget the apple pie, one of Americas greatest contributions to the culinary world is its cheese.

American Cheese is unbeatable in its consistency and its flavour is enough to complement any sandwich and burger. But it is not for everyone, and we can agree that it is not like cheddar or Gouda. However, it is perfect for grilled cheese sandwiches and burgers due to its salty smoothness.

American cheese is processed cheese, and each slice is wrapped in individual plastic wrappers. As it is processed cheese that means it is not real cheese. Heres everything you need to know about American cheese here in UK.

Are you ready? Lets get into it!

Don’t Miss: How Many Calories In Swiss Cheese

Lucerne American Style Cheese Product Loaf

Cheese, Smooth Melting, American Style

Pasteurized prepared cheese product. Melts better than cheddar cheese. SmartLabel: Scan for more food information. Per 1 oz: 90 calories 3.5 g sat fat 370 mg sodium 2 g total sugars. 100% money back guaranteed quality & satisfaction.

Nutrition Facts

Servings Per Container : 16

Best For Artisanal American: Saxelby Cheesemongers

Courtesy of Saxelby Cheesemongers

  • Tiny-production gems, many of which you wont find elsewhere

  • Great gift boxes

  • Pricey shipping, depending on your location

Anne Saxelby opened Saxelby Cheesemongers in 2006 in Manhattans historic Essex Street Market after cutting her teeth in cheese at New York Citys famous cheese shops. Now, its one of the best-known shops in the country, especially when it comes to small-production American cheese.

Online, you can choose from some of the best cheeses made in America or just go for the cheese of the month club. The gift selection is extensive and creative, with selections by producer and state. Theres also a beer lovers box, a dessert-pairing box, a woman-made box, and more. If you only want the best of what America has to offer, opt for the American Cheese Society Winners quintet or trio.

Recommended Reading: How Is Babybel Cheese Made

You May Like: What Kind Of Cheese Can You Have On Keto

The 10 Best Places To Order Cheese Online In 2022

  • A huge selection of domestic and international cheeses

  • Both small producers and big names are available

  • If you dont know what youre looking for, the selection may be overwhelming

If youre easily overwhelmed, iGourmets cheese selection could be a bit much. On the contrary, if youre seeking something special and just cant find it, iGourmet is the place to look. For instance, most shops have one water buffalo cheesecreamy, fresh mozzarella di bufala. iGourmet has nine water buffalo milk options, including buffalo milk butter, buffalo milk Gouda, and buffalo milk Gorgonzola.

iGourmet has deli cuts, all the international greatest hits, cheese in bulk, a solid sale selection, and accompaniments galore. There are also well thought-out sets and boxes, including sets of cheeses to pair with your favorite wines, from cabernet sauvignon to riesling to pinot noir.

Velveeta Or American Cheese

What’s the Best Feta at the Supermarket?
  • Line a small loaf pan with plastic wrap, leaving a few inches of excess on both sides of the pan. Alternatively, you may use smaller loaf-size containers.

  • Put the water in a saucepan and bring to a boil.

  • Combine the gelatine, milk powder, and salt in a blender and pulse to blend.

  • Add the boiling water to the blender and immediately pulse a few times.

  • Quickly add the cheddar cheese and process until smooth.

  • Working quickly, pour or spoon the mixture into the lined pan. Use a spatula to even the top. Cover with the excess plastic wrap and refrigerate for several hours or overnight.

  • Slice the cheese and use it for cheese and cracker snacks, sandwiches, grilled cheese, or add some to a cheese sauce or dip.

  • Wrap in plastic wrap and store in the refrigerator. Use within 2 weeks.

    You May Like: Where Can I Get Cheese Fries

    Best For An American Original: Sweet Grass Dairy

    Courtesy of Sweet Grass Dairy

    • Pricey shipping, depending on your location

    States like Vermont and Wisconsin get most of the credit for cheesemaking, but theres a burgeoning scene of small American cheesemakers making award-winning cheese in other parts of the country. Georgia-based Sweet Grass Dairy is a perfect example of small-batch American cheese done right.

    Using a system called rotational grazing, Sweet Grass Dairy ensures happy, pasture-fed cows. When you take a bite of the cheese, that grass-fed flavor speaks for itself. It offers a wide variety of cheese in the online shop, including decadent Camembert-style Green Hill and a crowd-pleasing pimento cheese. Smear either on your favorite baguette or pick up some southern-made charcuterie, jam, crackers, or pecans to pair.

    How Do I Make Cheese

    Basic Steps of How to Make Cheese

  • Step 1: Start With Fresh, Warm Milk. The nicer and the fresher the milk you use, the more delicious your cheese will be.
  • Step 2: Acidify the Milk.
  • Step 3: Add a Coagulant.
  • Step 4: Test for Gel Firmness.
  • Step 5: Cut the Curd.
  • Step 6: Stir, Cook & Wash the Curd.
  • Step 7: Drain the Curds.
  • Step 8: Salt and Age the Cheese.
  • Also Check: How To Melt Cheese For Nachos

    Kraft Deli Deluxe American 2%

    The only true American cheese in the batch, on par with what youd get from the deli counter. Its use of 2% milk puts it on a more even footing with the rest of the regular cheese food products. Packaged like a fancy single on the outside, it proved itself to be a regular Eliza Dolittle on the inside, as the un-resealable wrapper revealed annoyingly smushed-together slices with nothing to separate them. This basically defeats the purpose of buying sit-in-your-fridge-forever cheese.

    Nonetheless, it found redemption a few chews in. After a few seconds of nothing, a mild cheddar-like sharpness emerges as it warms up in your mouth, leaving you with a rich, salty aftertaste that lingers comfortably. With heat, it melted well naturallyfaster than Velveeta, actually, and second only to the original Kraft Single. In fact, it almost disappears when left to melt by itself. This was unexpected since cheese is supposed to stay solid longer than cheese food by theory of composition alone. Because it melted so quickly, though, microwaving it creates a skin, similar to the Borden.

    Best Budget: Caputos Market

    Bongards Yellow American Cheese

    Courtesy of Caputo’s

    • Cheeses go out of stock often

    Caputos Market in Salt Lake City is one of the best under-the-radar spots to shop for cheese, period. It stocks American originals and European favorites, and it even has an affinage program, in which it teams up with small producers to perfect its cheeses.

    Not only is there a range of delicious, affordable cheese options, but Caputo’s also offers affordable shipping pricestheres no need to pay $30 or more for shipping unless youre overnighting your order. If youre only trying one cheese, go for the house-aged cheddar. After being aged for 12 months, its buttery and potato-y with the faintest note of sweet horseradish.

    Recommended Reading: Is Chuck E Cheese Open On Saturdays

    Best Shopping Experience: Zingermans

    Courtesy of Zingerman’s

    • A range of domestic and international cheeses

    • Great tasting notes on every cheese

    • Cheeses go out of stock often

    Its hard not to love Zingermans of Ann Arbor, Michigan. Its quirky, genuine, and a place that values its employees. That same sort of thoughtfulness goes into the online cheese buying experience. Looking for cheese made with vegetarian rennet or cheese from a specific state? Maybe youre just looking for brunch cheese.

    The site’s search function is tailored to the customeryou can even search by the required shipping method . Each cheeses landing page tells its story, complete with tasting notes for the current batch. The gift options are also solid, too, with options by the origin and desired pairings.

    What Will The Us Government Do With 14 Billion Pounds Of Cheese

    The United States dairy surplus has reached a record high, rounding out at 1.4 billion pounds of cheese. Reports attempting to quantify this astonishing amount have deferred to metrics like enough to wrap around the U.S. Capitol. Suffice to say, nobodys suggesting we could consume it all.

    The nation eating this much cheese is not only mind-boggling: Its growing less and less likely. According to U.S. Department of Agriculture data, Americans have cut their milk consumption down from 35 pounds to an average of 15 per person annually. The excess is turned into cheese for storage and longevity . At the same time, government subsidies have continued to support dairy production, buying up surplus to keep prices steady. That leaves us with more cheese than anyone, even the experts, knows what to do with.

    What has changedand changed fairly noticeably and fairly recentlyis people are turning away from processed cheese, Cornell University agriculture economist Andrew Novakovic said in an interview with NPR. Its the same as it is for everything else: If youve got too much of something, the price has to go down until consumption rises.

    In the past, the U.S. government has supported dairy farmers through various programs and agencies, accumulating a staggering surplus with policies unique to this industry. What its done with that surplus has changed the American welfare state and diet forever.

    Also Check: Where Is Cabot Cheese Made

    Pasteurized Prepared Cheese Product :

    This category, and others like it, are not currently regulated by the FDA. No one knows exactly what is in these products! Some of them list cheese as the first ingredient on the label, while others do not, so there is clearly some variation per manufacturer. Most of the individually wrapped slices commonly known as American cheese fall under this heading.

    Best For Cheese And Charcuterie: Murrays Cheese

    How Government Cheese Became Welfare For Farmers
    • Many meat and cheese options

    • Gift boxes to choose from

    • Pricey shipping, depending on your location

    Need some prosciutto, too? How about a whole prosciutto leg? Once New York Citys quirkiest cheese shop, Murrays Cheese is now owned by Kroger, Americas largest supermarket chain by revenue. You may know Murrays for its cheese, but the brand shines in offering a charcuterie selection, too, featuring some of the greatest hits from around the world.

    Whether youre looking for venison pâté, small-batch pepperoni, or whole legs of prosciutto, this one-stop-shop has got you covered. It also stocks smoked fish and sausages, like andouille and breakfast links. If youre extra fancy, there are even truffle-infused options.

    Don’t Miss: How Much Potassium In Cottage Cheese

    How To Make American Cheese

    Americas Test Kitchen offers an approachable and appetizing recipe for homemade American cheese. Their version uses gelatin, an ingredient often found in American slices, to soften the texture of the cheese and remold it.

    Because it does not contain the emulsifiers frequently found in all categories of store-bought American cheese, this homemade version will be slightly less stable upon melting compared to purchased versions. Still, it is a good approximation of the original style of American cheese!

    Also Check: How Much Is A Bacon Egg Cheese Biscuit At Mcdonalds

    Can You Buy Government Cheese

    4.5/5You CAN buycheesecheese

    Like traditional processed American cheese, it consists of a variety of cheese types and other ingredients, such as emulsifiers, blended together, and may be made of any of Cheddar cheese, Colby cheese, cheese curd, or granular cheese.

    Also Know, is American cheese the same as government cheese? American cheese is simply one type of cheese. Government cheese is a term that was used disparagingly to indicate the quality of cheese the government issued to poor people whether they were welfare recipients, members of a Native American tribe on a reservation or incarcerated prisoners.

    Keeping this in view, does the government still give away cheese?

    Its moldy, its deteriorating we cant find a market for it, we cant sell it, and were looking to try to give some of it away. Now known as government cheese, the pungent-smelling cheese was ultimately distributed to the tune of 300 million pounds.

    Who makes the government cheese?

    James L. Kraft of Illinois patented a manufacturing process in 1916 that allowed for mass production of his famous orange cheeseproduct. Containing a mixture of colby and cheddar with curds and emulsifiers, the Kraft companys almost-cheese became enormously popular during the first half of the 20th century.

    Recommended Reading: How To Stop Eating Cheese

    Melting Cheese Slices Is That Easy

    This is my favorite way to make cheese sauce, because there is no mess and you can use the inexpensive cheese that you have on hand! It turns out amazing and you can cook just the amount you need each time.

    Whip up this nacho cheese in minutes for a great treat anytime you want cheese sauce. I could literally just eat it with tortilla chips. Yum!

    No need to stir in flour or any other ingredients. This is so simple and literally just cheese slices and water.

    What Is Government Cheese Wahlburgers

    Bongards® Yellow Processed American Cheese Block â 45#

    4.2/5Government cheesecheesecheese

    Government cheese is processed cheese provided to welfare beneficiaries, Food Stamp recipients, and the elderly receiving Social Security in the United States, as well as to food banks. The cheese, along with the butter and dehydrated powder, was stored in over 150 warehouses across 35 states.

    Also, what does government cheese taste like? If youve ever tasted whats known as government cheese, you wont soon forget it. Its flavor was described as somewhere between Velveeta and American cheese and smacked of humiliation or gratitude for the people who couldnt afford not to eat it. Its color, an almost neon orange, was eye-catching.

    Thereof, why does wahlburgers call it government cheese?

    Our cheese came from the food stamp program the government-run agency for poor families who couldnt afford to feed themselves without help.

    What is Wahl sauce at wahlburgers?

    Wahlburgers matches up their most of their burgers with Pauls Signature Wahl Sauce, which is a savory combination of ketchup, mayonnaise, sriracha, sautéed onions, and parsley. burger with lettuce, tomato, onion, government cheese, and house made pickles.

    Recommended Reading: Is Cottage Cheese On Keto

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This