What’s A Substitute For Butter In Mac And Cheese

Don't Miss

What Else Can I Add To My Mac & Cheese

The BEST Mac and Cheese to Make on Thanksgiving!

There are many add-ins that can go into mac and cheese. If it sounds good to you, then the flavor combinations will probably taste good too. Some of our favorite add-ins for mac and cheese are: hamgreen peppersmushroomsBut not all at the same time. What add-ins do you like to put in your mac and cheese?

Milk Substitutes For Mac N Cheese

If the reason that youre making the substitute is just because you dont have milk or arent able to obtain milk, then sour cream, cream cheese, butter or margarine are all good substitutes for milk in your mac and cheese. These substitutes will not work, however, for those who require a non-dairy diet.

How To Make Homemade Roux For A Creamy Sauce

To make a simple and flavorful roux, start by melting a stick of butter in a medium saucepan.

Whisk in the salt and pepper. A very important step is to continue stirring for a good 2-3 minutes until roux turns a bit darker in color. It becomes richer and even more fabulous.

Slowly whisk in the milk until mixture is thick and creamy. This step will take a couple minutes over medium heat.

Stir in cheese until creamy and cheese is melted through. I prefer a finely shredded mild cheddar. It melts quickly and has a perfect cheddar flavor.

Dont Miss: What Color Is Cheddar Cheese

You May Like: What Does Brick Cheese Taste Like

How To Change And Personalize Your Macaroni And Cheese Recipe

The pasta obviously for mac you use classic elbow macaroni, but I also love penne and corkscrew pastas for mac and cheese any pasta that holds lots of sauce is a good one to use for mac and cheese

The sauce how long you cook your roux effects the flavor, any spices you add and of course the types of cheeses you pick! Below is a video tutorial talking ALL about it! This recipe is the cheeses I like to use BUT you can mix other cheeses into your rotation for other flavors.

Finally to bake or not to bake Personally I like to mix my pasta and sauce and enjoy right away BUT some people like to pour the pasta and sauce into an oven safe pan and top with more cheese or bread crumbs and bake a bit but I like my pasta fresher!

The great part about starting with a bechamel sauce is that it holds together really well and doesnt separate. You do want to make sure you take the sauce off the heat and let it cool a little before adding the cheese if its too hot the cheese will clump together rather than melt into a smooth sauce. Add the cheese a little at a time, making sure its melted before adding more.

Read Also: How Long To Microwave Mac And Cheese

Can I Sub Water For Milk In Mac And Cheese

Truffle Mac and Cheese (vegetarian, GF option)  Honey ...

Yes, you can use water for milk in mac and cheese. However, we recommend using pasta water instead of plain water. Pasta water is the leftover water that you drain off the noodles after boiling them. This will help keep your noodles from seeming to be so watered down, like they might be with just plain water.

Read Also: Can You Put Sour Cream In Mac And Cheese

Gather & Measure The Ingredients

This easy mac and cheese recipe is super fast-paced once you start cooking, so it’s important to have all the ingredients measured and ready to go! As you can see there are only eight, common ingredients in this recipe that most of us have on hand at all times! We will discuss the ingredients and possible substitutions later in this post .

Keys To A Perfect Cheese Sauce

The only tricky part of making a cheese sauce like this is incorporating the milk into the roux. These tips will set you up for success.

  • Start with warm milk. Warming the milk a minute or two in the microwave will help it blend into the warm roux more easily.
  • Add the milk slowly. Add the milk slowly while whisking the roux. At first, the roux will thin out, then it will clump up. You might think all is lost at this point, but persevere. Continue whisking the milk and it will loosen into a creamy sauce.
  • Let bubble until slightly thickened. Once all the milk is added, let it bubble, stirring occasionally, until slightly thickened. Youre looking for a thickness thats somewhere between heavy cream and buttermilk. Stir in the grated cheese, let it melt, and youre almost ready for mac and cheese bliss.

Also Check: Where To Buy Farmers Cheese

Recommended Reading: What Kind Of Sauce Is On Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

Can You Use Water Instead Of Milk In Annie’s Mac And Cheese

You could use water instead of milk inmacaroni and cheese, but the result would likely berunnier and lack the full flavor macaroni and cheese issupposed to have. You can also go the other way, to increasethe flavor omit the milk and double the amount of butter,using real butter instead of margarine.

Keeping this in consideration, what can I use as a substitute for milk in mac and cheese?

Milk Substitutes for Macaroni andCheesePlain yogurt or sour cream works brilliantly as asubstitute for the milk in mac and cheese recipes andresults in a creamier, tangier dish.

Also Know, do you have to put milk in mac and cheese? Creamier Mac and Cheese Starts withMilkInstead of water, cook your pasta in milk! Now,you usually add milk later in the cooking process tomake the cheese sauce, but for an extra touch of lusciouscreaminess, incorporate the milk at the very beginning ofcooking.

Simply so, what can I substitute for milk in a recipe?

Water. You can use water in most bakingrecipes that call for milk. Use 1 cup of water and 1-1/2teaspoons of butter for every 1 cup of milk called for inthe recipe. The extra butter will help your baked goods staymoist.

Can you make mac and cheese with water instead of milk?

Use extra butter if you aren’tusing milk later, or if you just want it to tastebetter. I use up to half a stick, seriously. Add the cheesepowder and mix as best you can you won’t get itcompletely incorporated, but try.

You May Like Also

Does Mac And Cheese Need Butter

Daiya Dairy Free Cheddar Style Mac and Cheese Review ~ Taste Test Cheezy Mac ~ What’s Up Wednesday!

Butter is not included with packaged mac and cheese because of its short shelf life. Although it does make a difference in taste, you can still have a creamy and delicious macaroni and cheese without butter.

You may have run out of butter or are looking to make a slightly healthier macaroni and cheese.

Excluding butter can lower the calorie count, by decreasing the amount of fat used. Either way butter is not a requirement. Unlike baking foods which is more of an exact science.

The only cooking involved in mac and cheese is boiling the noodles.

Since butter is added after that is done. It has little effect on the actual cooking part. The rest is just mixing the ingredients together.

Packaged or boxed macaroni and cheese doesnt necessarily need butter. You may even find that some brands list butter as an optional ingredient.

Annies homegrown for example includes six easy steps to making the brands boxed macaroni and cheese.

The cooking instructions are very similar to other brands of macaroni and cheese. As opposed to Kraft Annies gives an optional option for unsalted butter.

Listed as a suggestion for a richer flavor. Other than that cooking directions are nearly identical.

  • Annies Brand
  • Trader Joes

Not saying that Annies is any better than Kraft, both of them probably taste better with butter or margarine in my opinion.

So besides butter adding flavor it also does serve other purposes. These become more important when making homemade mac and cheese.

Also Check: What Kind Of Cheese Is Baby Bell

Stovetop Mac And Cheese Option

I love the golden brown edges and top that baking the macaroni and cheese creates, but you dont need to bake it if you dont want to. For a stovetop mac and cheese, simply add the pasta to the cheese sauce and then let it sit, covered for a few minutes. This time gives the pasta a chance to absorb some of the sauce. You can also take a look at this easy macaroni and cheese recipe made on the stovetop.

Does Mac And Cheese Taste Bad Without Butter

As a general rule added fats such as butter help to give more flavor to a dish. Mac and cheese will still have a small amount of fat from the milk but adding butter makes for a even richer taste. The butter has nothing to do with the cooking process it just adds another layer of flavor before serving.

Mac and cheese wont taste bad without butter but its better with it. Most brands of boxed mac and cheese give you the option of adding butter/margarine. Otherwise you only need one extra ingredient not included and that is milk. I think its simply a suggestion because it does enhance the flavor but it isnt absolutely necessary.

Don’t Miss: What Sauce Is On Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

Why Do You Need Butter For Mac And Cheese

Butter is often listed as an additional ingredient for mac and cheese. But adding butter elevates the dish and its flavors.

Mac and cheese without butter, or any other kind of added fat, has a thin sauce and a bland flavor. Adding butter to mac and cheese makes the sauce rich and creamy. It also adds flavor to the dish.

But if you dont have butter available or simply dont want to use it, there are substitutes that you can use instead. Each of them brings a unique flavor to the dish.

Recommended Reading: What Is Good With Mac And Cheese

Water Or Chicken Broth

Cugini Cuisine: Ham and Cheese Macaroni Cups

In a pinch, water or chicken broth can be a replacement, but will yield a non-creamy dish with little flavor or consistency. Add seasonings and sweeteners to bulk up the flavor profile.

Also, consider using the pasta water from the pot of boiled noodles instead of water from the tap for an extra boost of texture and flavor.

Substitution ratio: Use equal parts.

Flavor profile: Little to no added flavor. Add flavor and extra butter as desired.

Creaminess : 1

Read Also: What Sauce Is On Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

Make The Cheese Sauce

While the macaroni is cooking, make the cheese sauce. It’s really easy but there are a few notes that we’ll go over to ensure your success!

Make a Roux

This homemade mac and cheese sauce starts with a roux. What is a roux? It’s a mixture of fat and flour that is used to create thick sauces. Start by melting the butter and then adding the dry ingredients .

Use a whisk to combine the ingredients until the mixture is homogenous . Let it cook for about 60 seconds before moving on!

Add wet ingredients.

After the roux has cooked for 60 seconds, add the milk and whisk the mixture really well. Add the sour cream or Greek yogurt and whisk again. At this point the mixture will be fairly runny. Cook over medium heat whisking every 10-15 seconds until the sauce starts to thicken.

Do NOT let this mixture boil! If you do you may end up with a mac and cheese sauce that is too thick. Once the sauce has thickened enough to stick to a spatula, turn the heat to low. Then it’s time for the next step…

Add the cheese & whisk until smooth

Add the cheese and whisk until the sauce is smooth and all the cheese is melted. This will take 1-2 minutes over low heat. At this point it is important to taste the cheese sauce and adjust the salt/garlic according to your tastes!

Why Butter Is Used

As mentioned earlier butter is used for boxed mac and cheese mainly for flavor. The creaminess of the cheese comes from the added milk. Which is why whole milk is usually recommended.

Although butter will thicken the cheese slightly. Due to the milk fats present in the butter.

Skipping on the butter will lead to a slightly thinner macaroni and cheese.

Because butter is mostly fat, it mixes well with flour to make a base for sauces. This is known as a roux. Which is so I could paste that can be used to thicken sauces.

In the case of homemade mac and cheese. The roux is used for the cheese.

This is done by melting butter and adding in flour and stirring together. Cheese is then added to this mixture.

Adding butter also helps to keep the mac and cheese from being too dry. Since the butter is more oily it will help retain more moisture.

Some butter is a flavor enhancing ingredient in most boxed macaroni. When it comes to homemade mac and cheese, butter can be used to thicken the cheese sauce. Making it a much more important ingredient.

Also Check: Is Sour Cream Good In Mac And Cheese

Mac And Cheese Without Butter Recipe

If you want to make mac and cheese without butter or any added fat, you can easily do so. It tastes delicious and you can use different kinds of spices to make it flavorful.

When making mac and cheese without butter, you make the roux with milk and flour and dont add any additional fat. To make it creamy and rich, you should use full-fat milk. You can also use raw, low-fat, no-fat, or non-dairy milk. But full-fat milk makes the mac and cheese creamy.

To make mac and cheese without butter, cook the macaroni al dente, drain the water and set it aside. Then, in a pan, add 2 cups of milk and flour. Stir them on low heat. When mixed, add one more cup of milk. Stir continuously for about 3-5 minutes. Then, add cooked macaroni, cheese, salt, pepper, and chili flakes. Stir until all of the cheese melts. Serve hot.

Let me tell you the recipe in complete detail.

How Much Greek Yogurt Should I Substitute

How to Make Kraft Dinner without milk or butter

Use the same amount of greek yogurt as you would butter. Add more if you want more of a tangy taste, but then reduce the amount of milk.

Make sure you add the greek yogurt in at the same time as the milk and cheese powder, so it gets well incorporated into the sauce. If you add it as an afterthought, the taste will be much stronger.

Don’t Miss: Does Babybel Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated

Buttermilk Mac And Cheese Recipe:

During this national social distancing project, Ive been doing what many of you are probably doing cleaning. Closets, shelves, drawer, underneath furniture. You name it, Ive probably cleaned it. While organizing a closet, I found several notebooks that belonged to my Granny.

Ive really enjoyed flipping through these notebooks to see what recipes she was attracted to. I found this amazing baked macaroni and cheese recipe in one of her notebooks and it was torn from a magazine right beside Country Fried Steak, another treasure.

This creamy mac and cheesy makes a huge pan, making it great to share. Its already going on the menu for the next holiday, and I know its going to be requested over and over and over. I shared some with my parents, and my mom was in awe about how fluffy this version is. To quote her winner winner, chicken dinner.

I love my Moms mac and cheese hers is also a baked recipe but it has a thicker, denser texture. The addition of 6 beaten eggs forms almost a light, custard texture that makes this version hard to resist. If you arent feeding a crowd or want a quick stove top mac and cheese dish, try our Skillet Macaroni and Cheese.

Can I Use Mayo Instead Of Butter In Mac And Cheese

Using mayonnaise in place of butter from mac and cheese. This is doable and you can find some ingredients for this online.

Claiming to be a very creamy mac and cheese. But as one recipe notes the mayonnaise actually levels out cheese flavor. That way you dont get overwhelmed by the amount of cheese you use.

Similar to yogurt mayonnaise is not typically thought to be used in mac and cheese.

because both of them have a tangy and almost sour flavor.

You may find that these ingredients are better suited for a baked mac and cheese. Rather than a stove top quick mix version.

Recommended Reading: Sour Cream Or Cream Cheese In Mac And Cheese

Directions To Make Mac And Cheese Without Butter

It is simple to make mac and cheese without butter. Let me tell you how.

  • Fill a pot with water and add the macaroni to it. Place the pot on heat and cook the macaroni al dente. In other words, cook it until it is just firm.
  • Then, drain all the water in a colander and put the cooked macaroni in a bowl. Set aside.
  • In a pan, add 2 cups of milk. Place the pan on low heat. Add in the flour and stir continuously.
  • When the flour and milk have mixed and no lumps have formed, add in the remaining one cup of milk. Stir continuously for about 3-5 minutes until it becomes thick.
  • Then, add the cooked macaroni, cheese, salt, pepper, and chili flakes to the pan. Keep stirring until all the ingredients combine.
  • If you think the mac and cheese are too thick, you can add milk to it until you reach your desired consistency. Your creamy and delicious mac and cheese is ready to be served.
  • Nutritional Breakdown of Mac And Cheese

    Here is a table thatll tell you the nutritional breakdown of this recipe.


    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This