Where To Buy Cooper Cheese

Don't Miss

Its The Home That Makes It Homestyle Mac And Cheese

Cooper’s Hill Cheese Rolling

Thats really the final takeaway. However, you choose to make your homestyle mac and cheese, whatever you decide to add, the best add-in is when you make it, at home, for the people you love.

Because thats the best part of mac and cheeseenjoying it where youre comfortable, sharing it with family, and making memories youll hold onto for the rest of your life.

We hope theres plenty of Cooper® Sharp Homestyle Mac and Cheese in your future. And if you do make this recipe, why not share it with us and your thousand closest friends on , , , and ?

Wed love to see what you do with it.

Happy mac and cheesing!

How Much Does Instacart Delivery Or Pickup Cost

  • Delivery fees start at $3.99 for same-day orders over $35. Fees vary for one-hour deliveries, club store deliveries, and deliveries under $35.
  • Service fees vary and are subject to change based on factors like location and the number and types of items in your cart. Orders containing alcohol have a separate service fee.
  • Tipping is optional but encouraged for delivery orders. It’s a great way to show your shopper appreciation and recognition for excellent service. 100% of your tip goes directly to the shopper who delivers your order.
  • There may be a “pickup fee” on your pick up order that is typically $1.99 for non-Express members. Express membership waives this like it would a delivery fee.
  • Pick up orders have no service fees, regardless of non-Express or Express membership.

How Should You Store Cheese Once It Arrives

Cheese loves humidity and will do best if its in your crisper drawer. If your cheese arrived in plastic wrap, its best to repackage it in butcher paper.

Unless you plan to cook with it, never freeze cheese. Freezing will compromise its texture and flavor. Its not a huge deal if you freeze a bag of shredded mozzarella for pizza, but freezing a beautiful round of Camembert is a tragedy that cheesemongers will weep over.

Don’t Miss: How Long To Microwave Mac And Cheese

Best Budget: Caputos Market

Courtesy of Caputo’s

  • A range of domestic and international cheeses

  • Exclusive cave-aged cheeses

  • Cheeses go out of stock often

Caputos Market in Salt Lake City is one of the best under-the-radar spots to shop for cheese, period. It stocks American originals and European favorites, and it even has an affinage program, in which it teams up with small producers to perfect its cheeses.

Not only is there a range of delicious, affordable cheese options, but Caputo’s also offers affordable shipping pricestheres no need to pay $30 or more for shipping unless youre overnighting your order. If youre only trying one cheese, go for the house-aged cheddar. After being aged for 12 months, its buttery and potato-y with the faintest note of sweet horseradish.

Best For An American Original: Sweet Grass Dairy

Where to Buy  Cooper Cheese

Courtesy of Sweet Grass Dairy

  • A range of cheese styles, from Brie to pimento

  • A small, sustainable producer

  • Pricey shipping, depending on your location

States like Vermont and Wisconsin get most of the credit for cheesemaking, but theres a burgeoning scene of small American cheesemakers making award-winning cheese in other parts of the country. Georgia-based Sweet Grass Dairy is a perfect example of small-batch American cheese done right.

Using a system called rotational grazing, Sweet Grass Dairy ensures happy, pasture-fed cows. When you take a bite of the cheese, that grass-fed flavor speaks for itself. It offers a wide variety of cheese in the online shop, including decadent Camembert-style Green Hill and a crowd-pleasing pimento cheese. Smear either on your favorite baguette or pick up some southern-made charcuterie, jam, crackers, or pecans to pair.

Read Also: How Do You Bake Mac And Cheese

Give It That Homestyle Feeling

Now, if you just cant wait, you can go ahead and eat your mac and cheese right away. Because if you stop here, youve got yourself a delicious classic mac and cheese, and well never fault you for wanting to dig into that.

But you came here for homestyle mac and cheese. So heres where we get to make that magic happen.

Whilst resisting the near-constant urge to taste-test your mac and cheese out of existence, pour the whole lot of it into a 3-quart casserole dish. Gently spread it out into all four corners.

Then well need to top the whole thing with breadcrumbs or crushed crackers .


Youre welcome to just buy breadcrumbs from the store, but if youre feeling especially industrious, theyre fun to make yourself. All you need is bread, an oven and something to break the bread up with. Could be a food processor or a rolling pin. Or a heavy book. Or your own fists of fury.

Just place the bread slices into a 300°F oven to dry them out for about 15 minutes. Remove them from the oven and either pulse in a food processor or put the slices into a sealed bag and break them up with the blunt-force tool of your choosing.

Sprinkle the breadcrumbs or crackers over the macaroni and cheese until everything is covered. Then place the casserole dish into the oven and bake for about 25 to 30 minutes.

Pear Date & Cognac Chutney

We dont have any additional info for this product just yet. Check back as were continually adding info about our products.

Prices and availability are subject to change without notice. Offers are specific to store listed above and limited to in-store. Promotions, discounts, and offers available in stores may not be available for online orders. The information provided on this website, including special diets and nutritional information, is for reference purposes and not intended as medical or healthcare information or advice. Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and/or different information than shown on our website. You should not rely solely on the information presented here and you should always read labels, warnings, and directions before using or consuming a product. The information provided on this website should not be relied upon to make health-related decisions.

Also Check: Where Do I Buy Cheese Curds

Best For Artisanal American: Saxelby Cheesemongers

Courtesy of Saxelby Cheesemongers

  • Tiny-production gems, many of which you wont find elsewhere

  • Great gift boxes

  • Pricey shipping, depending on your location

Anne Saxelby opened Saxelby Cheesemongers in 2006 in Manhattans historic Essex Street Market after cutting her teeth in cheese at New York Citys famous cheese shops. Now, its one of the best-known shops in the country, especially when it comes to small-production American cheese.

Online, you can choose from some of the best cheeses made in America or just go for the cheese of the month club. The gift selection is extensive and creative, with selections by producer and state. There’s also a beer lovers box, a dessert-pairing box, a woman-made box, and more. If you only want the best of what America has to offer, opt for the American Cheese Society Winners quintet or trio.

Cooper Sharp Black Pepper Cheese

The World’s Craziest Competition: Gloucestershire Cheese Rolling at Cooper’s Hill | Quirky Customs

Okay, so this isnt so much an add-in as an alternate, but its our favorite way to add a little kick to your mac and cheese. Cooper® Sharp Black Pepper cheese takes the same creamy deliciousness of Cooper® Sharp and adds just the right amount of black pepper spiciness to the mix. Its like giving your mac and cheese a bit of attitude.

You May Like: What Kind Of Cheese To Put On A Charcuterie Board

What Do You Look For When Buying Cheese Online


In general, cheesemongers will advise you to order less cheese more often, rather than stocking up, but sometimes we go overboard. Should you be buying in bulk, make sure to eat softer cheeses, like Brie and burrata, first. The harder cheeses, like parmesan and cheddar, can last months in your fridge as opposed to a few weeks for the softer stuff.


Your cheese will likely come packaged in butcher paperand thats where it should remain. Plastic wrap will suffocate cheese and impart unpleasant flavors.


Many shops offer assortment boxes that make a lovely cheese plate. Should you be curating your own cheese board selection, stick to a range of milk types and textures. An old cheesemonger saying is something old , something new , something stinky, something blue.

Welcome To Dairy Central

When Dairy Central first opened its doors to its customers in the Greater Toronto Area, our goal was to provide commendable customer service by adding a personal touch to our orders and their fulfilling.

Currently, our team distributes and has access to over 5,000 products within the Greater Toronto Area. Moreover, we are also expanding our product list everyday to meet and exceed market requirements. Our target demographic consists of restaurants, academic institutions, hotels, multiple retail stores, and many more. However, due to our vast number of products, our clientele can include almost anyone.

If you want fresh products delivered to your location urgently, then Dairy Central is right for you!

Variety of Products

We offer competitive prices and a great variety of products. Along with name brands, we have expanded our market reach and carry niche food & beverage items.

Quick Delivery Times

Our extremely streamlined inventory management system and highly professional drivers ensure quick delivery times, as much as a guaranteed next day delivery.

Small Minimum Order

Our client list includes enterprises of different sizes and with that, we offer small minimum orders to ensure that your shelves are stocked at the end of the day.

Customizable Orders

Our efficient online ordering system and trained staff allows you to have customized shopping lists that meet your specific requirements.

Also Check: Does Chuck E Cheese Still Use Tokens

Best Organic: Cowgirl Creamery

  • Cant just buy one or two cheeses

If youre a cheese lover, youve likely already heard about Cowgirl Creamerys incredible cheese. Mount Tam, its triple cream Brie-style cheese, is mushroomy, creamy, and a total dreamboat. Perhaps youre more of a Red Hawk fan, with its distinctive orange rind and characteristic meaty funk.

What you may not know is that all of Cowgirl Creamery’s cheeses are made with organic milk. Whereas certified organic produce isnt all that hard to find, certified organic cheese is. Even if a cheesemaker follows organic practices, the certification is expensive and very strict, but Cowgirl values sustainability and thinks cheese tastes better when its made with organic milk.

The store doesnt sell its cheese piecemeal on the website , but its collections feature its flagship cheeses, plus wonderful small-batch meat, jam, crackers, and other accouterments.

Now Make This Homestyle Mac And Cheese Yours

Where to Buy

There you have it! Quite possibly the most delicious homestyle mac and cheese youll ever eat, serve or just plain behold in wide-eyed wonder.

Now, we love our homestyle mac and cheese just the way it is but we also dont mind giving it a bit of a twist now and again. So consider this your official authorization to get a little creative. There are any number of things to add to mac and cheese, but here are a few ideas to get you started.

Don’t Miss: Who Sells Lobster Mac And Cheese

Best Shopping Experience: Zingermans

Courtesy of Zingerman’s

  • A range of domestic and international cheeses

  • Great tasting notes on every cheese

  • Cheeses go out of stock often

Its hard not to love Zingermans of Ann Arbor, Michigan. Its quirky, genuine, and a place that values its employees. That same sort of thoughtfulness goes into the online cheese buying experience. Looking for cheese made with vegetarian rennet or cheese from a specific state? Maybe youre just looking for brunch cheese.

The site’s search function is tailored to the customeryou can even search by the required shipping method . Each cheeses landing page tells its story, complete with tasting notes for the current batch. The gift options are also solid, too, with options by the origin and desired pairings.

What Happens If The Original Cooper Brand Sharp American Cheese Is Out Of Stock And I Need To Give Specific Instructions

  • Find Best Match: By default, your shopper will use their best judgement to pick a replacement for your item.
  • Pick Specific Replacement: You can pick a specific alternative for the shopper to purchase if your first choice is out-of-stock.
  • Don’t Replace: For items you’d rather not replace, choose “Don’t replace” to get a refund if the item is out of stock.

Read Also: Where Can I Get A Good Grilled Cheese

The 10 Best Places To Order Cheese Online In 2021

  • A huge selection of domestic and international cheeses

  • Both small producers and big names are available

  • If you dont know what youre looking for, the selection may be overwhelming

If youre easily overwhelmed, iGourmets cheese selection could be a bit much. On the contrary, if youre seeking something special and just cant find it, iGourmet is the place to look. For instance, most shops have one water buffalo cheesecreamy, fresh mozzarella di bufala. iGourmet has nine water buffalo milk options, including buffalo milk butter, buffalo milk Gouda, and buffalo milk Gorgonzola.

iGourmet has deli cuts, all the international greatest hits, cheese in bulk, a solid sale selection, and accompaniments galore. There are also well thought-out sets and boxes, including sets of cheeses to pair with your favorite wines, from cabernet sauvignon to riesling to pinot noir.

*** Thanksgiving Recipes ***

Cheese Rolling Coopers Hill 2017

These roasted brussels sprouts get a fair amount of spice from the crushed red pepper flakes, which cuts…

After trying every turkey-roasting method under the sun, I’ve finally settled on this as absolutely the…

We love how the cinnamon-scented streusel topping lets the juicy berries peek through.

Italian sausage and a heap of Parmesan cheese lend signature flair to the easy Thanksgiving dressing…

It’s all about the layers and ruffles in this dramatic seasonal pie.

Poach quince in rosé with a dash of cocktail bitters and a few warm spices, then assemble into a tart…

Leave the sausage, nuts, dried fruit behind in favor of this easy, vegetarian-friendly stuffing recipe…

Alton Brown’s turkey brine recipe from Good Eats will give you a flavorful Thanksgiving turkey with juicy…

Bone-in turkey breasts are easy to find, and as impressive as a whole bird when you roast them in butter…

This recipe was handed down by my great-grandmother. It is a family favorite that we make every Thanksgiving….

Cutting leeks into large pieces gives them a presence equal…

This crunchy crumble is the perfect topping for an ice cream sundae, easy apple crumble, or our Build-Your-Own…

Recommended Reading: How Much Is The Chuck E Cheese Play Pass

Add The Cooper Sharp Cheese

If you have your Cooper® cheese sliced at the deli, just take those slices and tear them into small pieces. Or, if you prefer to get your Cooper® as a whole loaf or a good-sized chunk, you can shred it using a cheese grater.

Cooper® shreds best when its nice and cold, so make sure to leave it in the fridge until you need it. You may even want to put it in the freezer for 20 minutes before shredding.

Once youve got your Cooper® Sharp shredded, torn, or otherwise reduced to tiny little cheese shards, reduce the roux to low heat and add in the cheese. Stir constantly until all the Cooper® cheese is melted, which will probably take about 5 to 7 minutes.

Resist the urge to just stop here and eat your cheese sauce on its own.

You will be rewarded for your self-control. Promise.

Do this:

Then this:


Want to speed up meal prep? Our Mason Jar Cooper® Cheese Sauce is just the thing. Its easy to make ahead of time.

How To Order Cooper Sharp Cheese

  • Does Blue Cheese Spoil?
  • The Cooper company makes American cheese that it distributes to various grocery stores in the Northeastern states, but it can be difficult to track down if you do not live in that area of the country. Cooper Sharp American Cheese tastes similar to standard American cheese, but it has a tangy, strong flavor, like other sharp cheeses. Fortunately, there is a way to order Cooper Sharp American Cheese online. Buy the cheese in bricks as large as 5 lbs.

    Go to a website that sells Cooper Sharp American Cheese. Two of the websites that sell this product are ShopRite and CubaCheese.

    Select the type and size of cheese you want to order, which will be either Cooper Sharp White or Cooper Sharp Yellow. As of January 2010, ShopRite sells a range of .25- to 3-lb. bricks of Cooper cheese, and CubaCheese sells Cooper cheese in 5-lb. bricks.

    Also Check: How Do You Make Mac And Cheese In The Microwave

    A Long List Of Fresh Products To Choose From

    We distribute over 5,000 products from reputable brands and continuously adhere to the quality standards so that you get nothing but the best for your purchase. Our product list ranges from dairy to bakery, that includes milk, cheese, yogurt, soft-drinks, bar-mixes, water, and bread you name it, weve got it. We also pride ourselves in carrying name brands such as Sealtest, Natrel, and Astro to name a few.

    How Long Does Cheese Last

    Buy Sliced White Cooper Sharp Cheese Online

    Harder cheeses, in general, are less perishable than soft cheeses. Fresh cheeses, like mozzarella or chevre, should be eaten within a week of purchase. Most soft cheeses will last seven to 14 days in your fridge. Hard cheeses will last at least 14 days and sometimes longersomething like Parmigiano Reggiano will last just about forever.

    Read Also: Can You Have Cheese On A Low Carb Diet

    Best For Families: Hickory Farms

    Courtesy of Hickory Farms

    • Many assortments to choose from

    • Budget-friendly

    • Not many options for the foodie or those who prefer to buy from small producers

    Next time youre shopping for a range of ages, consider Hickory Farms. The site has a range of crowd-pleasing cheese options, from a classic orange cheddar to a smoked cheese flight, plus simple, but thoughtful gift boards and baskets .

    You wont find Brie, manchego, or other international options here, but you will find a sausage and cheese gift basket, fruit and cheese baskets, cheese spread flights, and other delightful surprises. Cheese lovers of all ages will appreciate fun flavored options, such as the bacon and smoked cheddar blend, which, by the way, would be amazing on a grilled cheese sandwich.

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This